Artist Accuses Playstation Game of Lifting Her Work; Studio Admits to ‘Oversight'

Sony
'Marathon,' the upcoming multiplayer game by Sony-owned Bungie, has been accused of using artwork from an independent artist without permission.
Fern Hook, a 30-year-old independent artist in Scotland, noticed something familiar about 'Marathon,' the upcoming video game by Bungie, the studio that created the Halo series and is now owned by Sony Interactive Entertainment.
'Marathon,' she said, is 'covered with assets lifted from poster designs I made in 2017,' all in the alpha version of the game, which allowed the general public to play an early version of the multiplayer shooter. She became suspicious when the game was announced in a 2023 trailer, but nothing appeared to her to be derivative at first.
In mid-April, content creators began publishing early videos of 'Marathon' gameplay. She said she 'very quickly' began to spot her work. Hook's futuristic iconography and font designs are posted on social media sites like Tumblr and X as far back as 2017, and similar features are seen all over the environment and the objects within 'Marathon,' she said, pointing out the similarities through her social media on Thursday.
'It was kind of vindicating to see direct plagiarism because it meant I wasn't crazy for feeling so uncomfortable with the overall direction,' Hook told The Washington Post. 'I kept quiet about it because I was advised to seek legal action, but … I don't have enough time or money to fly out to the U.S. to pursue an unwinnable court case against Sony.'
When The Post contacted Sony about the allegations, a spokesperson pointed to Bungie's statement on social media.
The 'Marathon' developer team said on X that it was looking into 'a concern regarding unauthorized use of artist decals in Marathon and confirmed that a former Bungie artist included these in a texture sheet that was ultimately used in-game.'
'The issue was unknown by our existing art team, and we are still reviewing how this oversight occurred,' the studio posted on X, adding that it had contacted Hook to discuss the issue and was 'committed to do right by the artist.'
The studio said it is conducting a review of the game's artwork, specifically the images made by the former artist, and implementing 'stricter checks to document all artist contributions.'
The allegations could be particularly damaging for Bungie and 'Marathon,' which has struggled to gain positive press during a financially challenging era for the studio. 'Marathon' is a classic 1990s computer shooter with a harrowing science-fiction narrative. The reboot, expected to be released in September, throws that out to instead focus on an always-online, multiplayer-only competitive shooting game.
The most widely acclaimed aspect of the new game was its art design, which goes for bold colors and a 1990s futurism vibe. The art style is not original, especially in games, with PlayStation's Wipeout series being an early adopter. But the clean, shiny aesthetic is rare in a modern video games industry typically obsessed with gritty realism.
This is not the first time Bungie has been accused of using the work of an independent artist. In 2024, a fan made art of a toy gun designed in the style of Bungie's earlier game 'Destiny 2,' which was then used as a model for a game-themed Nerf gun. Bungie later said it would credit and compensate the artist.
Hook said this is also not the first time she has seen her work lifted, and she has made posts over the years alleging other organizations tracing and lifting her work. She said she relies on donations for her various online projects, and this recent incident has seen hundreds of people donating money in support.
Hook also composes drum and bass music and sound design for games under the name N2, and produces freelance art work under the name ANTIREAL. She co-runs a design and software consultancy firm called Superstructure as well.
'I'd kind of had to learn to shut up about these cases because they've happened so constantly over the past 10 years,' she said. 'It was tiring to be viewed as 'someone who complains' more than as an artist. But the response this time has been overwhelmingly understanding and I'm extremely thankful for the support.'

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

Tokyo Weekender

11-06-2025

• Tokyo Weekender

Switch 2 Smashes Nintendo's Record, Selling 3.5 Million Units in Four Days

Nintendo announced on Wednesday that it had sold a record 3.5 million Switch 2 units worldwide in the first four days after the launch of the console. The astonishing figure surpasses the first month's sales of the original Switch (2.7 million units) and Sony's PlayStation 5 (3.4 million units). The former went on to sell more than 152 million units, making it the third best-selling game console of all time, behind the PlayStation 2 and the Nintendo DS. Switch 2 Sales Predicted To Exceed Company's Expectations Last month, Nintendo said that Switch 2 sales would reach 15 million during the current financial year which ends on March 31, 2026. Analysts, however, consider that to be a modest target set by the company. Serkan Toto, CEO and founder of gaming industry consultancy Kantan Games, believes it will sell over 20 million units in the first year. He told CNBC , 'All signals prior to launch pointed to significant demand, and I believe we will see further records broken over the next weeks or months.' The coveted console, which is similar in design to its predecessor, though has a bigger screen and larger, redesigned controllers, was released in most regions on June 5. Around the world, excited gamers lined up outside electronic stores, waiting for the midnight opening. In Japan alone, around 2.2 million people applied for a lottery system to buy the console. Even before it went on sale, Nintendo reportedly started shipping Switch 2 branded 'Out of Stock' signs to retailers. Mario Kart World Mario Kart World was also released on June 5 as the launch game for the Nintendo Switch 2. It has added an open world to the series, providing players with the opportunity to race across a giant connected map from one circuit to another. Other exciting titles include the 3D platforming action-adventure game, Donkey Kong Bananza , which will be released on July 17, and Kirby Air Riders, a new title from Super Smash Bros.' director Masahiro Sakurai, which will come out later this year. Related Posts Nintendo Announces the Successor to the Nintendo Switch Bricks and Buttons: The Lego Nintendo Game Boy How to Find Tokyo's Secret Nintendo Bar: 84 Hashi Cafe

Asahi Shimbun

10-06-2025

• Asahi Shimbun

Nintendo's Switch 2 soups up the graphics, but does it deliver the games?

WASHINGTON--I'm cruising around Bowser's Castle with my old pal Toad. It's not exactly relaxing, what with all the lava pits and banana peels and turtle shells littering the road. Add 23 other characters — is that a cow driving? — who are trying to get to the finish line first, and it's chaos. The hectic, high-speed insanity of any race in the new Mario Kart World would have caused the eight-year-old Switch console to wheeze a bit. And that's why we've got the Switch 2 ($449.99), the souped-up sequel to Nintendo's popular home-and-portable hybrid. It looks prettier, too. The 7.9-inch portable display (up from 6.2 inches) boosts the resolution to 1020p (from 720p), and while the LCD screen isn't quite as sharp as an OLED screen might have been, it's much cleaner than the original recipe Switch. It looks even better when connected to an HDTV since it now supports 4K and HDR. Nintendo has always stood apart from the technological arms race that fans of Sony's PlayStation and Microsoft's Xbox obsess over, insisting that first-rate games don't necessarily depend on high-powered computer chips. But you could feel the strain in 2023's The Legend of Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom, with its at-times blurry graphics and sluggish framerate. The Switch 2, with a faster framerate of 120 fps, corrects much of the fuzziness. That's not to say it comes close to matching the high-definition performance of the PlayStation 5 or the Xbox X/S. If you're expecting the jaw-dropping graphics of, say, Ubisoft's Assassin's Creed Shadows ... well, no. There is good news for those of us who have gotten weary of the old Switch's dinky 32 gigabytes of internal storage. The Switch 2 multiplies that by eight, for 256 GB. Of course, flashier games take up more space, so if you want more room you'll have to invest in a microSD Express card — which is a bit pricier than the standard memory card used in most portable devices. The Switch 2's Joy-Con controllers have undergone some tinkering. As before, you can attach them to the sides of the screen if you're playing on the go. If you're at home, you can attach them to a doohickey that feels more like a traditional joystick. Either way, they're now more firmly connected with magnets, which provide a satisfying snap. Both the left and right Joy-Cons now include an optical mouse, which you can use by placing the controller on its edge and rolling it around on a table. (Nintendo says you can also use it on your pants, but I prefer using a clipboard on my lap.) It remains to be seen how many Switch 2 games will call for a mouse, but 2K's port of Sid Meier's Civilization VII seems like a good candidate. And then there's a new button labeled 'C' on the right-hand Joy-Con. That calls up GameChat, which lets you start up a conversation with other players — provided you've all taken the time to register yourselves as friends. (Eventually, you'll also need to subscribe to the Nintendo Switch Online service, but that requirement doesn't kick in until March 31, 2026.) The microphone is built into the Switch 2, though if you want to upgrade to video chat, you'll need to buy a separate Nintendo camera. Finally, there's GameShare, which lets you play selected titles with other Switch users even if they don't own the software. Nintendo has been emphasizing the new social features in its marketing, though it feels like it's catching up to the competition. The kids I know who play Fortnite or Minecraft on competing consoles seem to have figured out long ago how to chat with their pals. Welcome to the 2010s? As with any console launch, the driving question is: Does it have the games? There are just a couple of Switch 2 exclusives out now: Mario Kart World and Nintendo Switch 2 Welcome Tour, a $10 demo package that really should have been free. There are some new-to-Nintendo ports of excellent titles like Split Fiction and Cyberpunk 2077. You can get upgrades of classics like the last two Legend of Zelda adventures. And the Switch 2 is fully backward-compatible, so you can play everything that came out for the Switch as well as a substantial library of older titles. There's no other machine that will let you play future installments of beloved franchises like Zelda, Super Mario Bros., Super Smash Bros. and Animal Crossing. None of those have been announced yet, but some marquee names — Donkey Kong and Kirby — will star in Switch 2 exclusives later this year. There's plenty of competition out there, though, and not just in the TV-connected console market Switch shares with the PlayStation and the Xbox. Nintendo no longer has the portable market to itself, thanks to Valve's SteamDeck. Some models of that device cost less than the Switch 2, and it already has a huge library of PC games. Meanwhile, Microsoft announced over the weekend that it's teaming up with Asus on the ROG Xbox Ally, a handheld that will be out before Christmas. Honestly, we'll probably have a better idea of the Switch's quality a few years down the line, after developers get a handle on what the new hardware can do. If you're dying to get back behind the wheel with Mario, Luigi and Princess Peach right now, though, you know what you need to do.

Nikkei Asia

06-06-2025

• Nikkei Asia

Letter from Nikkei Asia's editor: Nintendo's Switch 2 is out -- now the game is getting one

Hello from Tokyo. Nintendo released its new game console, the Nintendo Switch 2, on Thursday. However, due to supply constraints and a strict and complex lottery-based sales system, eager fans may have to wait quite a while before getting their hands on the device. Our news editor, who once covered Nintendo as a reporter, shared his disappointment after failing to win the lottery on Wednesday. The Switch 2 faces two major challenges. The first is whether Nintendo can ramp up supply in time for the holiday shopping season, amid global disruptions linked to Trump-era tariffs. The second, longer-term challenge is whether the company can break its cycle of hit-and-miss consoles following the massive success of the current Switch. Headquartered in Kyoto, Nintendo stands out among Japanese tech companies. It entered the game console market over 40 years ago, following the success of its portable Game & Watch device, which used display technology originally developed for calculators. Even as tech giants like Sony and Microsoft entered the gaming industry, Nintendo has managed to maintain its market share. In recent years, it has held its ground against the rise of smartphone and PC gaming. Nintendo has two key strengths. The first is its hardware development philosophy, known as "lateral thinking with withered technology." Just as it once adapted calculator-based tech for gaming, Nintendo has consistently introduced new forms of entertainment by creatively combining widely available, mature technologies. The second strength lies in its roster of game characters, developed over more than 40 years. With franchises like Mario and Zelda, it offers games beloved by players of all ages. Will the Switch 2 make it onto your gift list in time for the holiday season? Please stay tuned to Nikkei Asia for the latest updates. My suggested reads 1. The grocery retail market in the Philippines is being shaken up by the rapid expansion of two so-called hard discounters, Dali and O!Save. Characterized by limited selections of mostly own-brand products, a relentless focus on cost efficiency and noticeably lower prices than their competitors, they are carving out a significant niche. 2. In May, Nissan's new CEO, Ivan Espinosa, unveiled a drastic restructuring plan echoing the carmaker's cost-cutting strategy of 1999, which succeeded by slashing over 20,000 jobs and closing factories. But today, Nissan faces far tougher challenges, including the shift toward electric vehicles and growing competition from China. 3. In an exclusive interview, Bank of Thailand Gov. Sethaput Suthiwartnarueput warns that U.S. tariffs and the resulting influx of diverted goods into Southeast Asia's second-largest economy could hurt industries from tires to furniture, with the real impact likely to hit in the second half of the year. 4. South Korea's new president, Lee Jae-myung, faces urgent trade talks with the U.S. as the pause on President Donald Trump's "Liberation Day" tariffs ends next month. With major implications for South Korea's economy, Lee must act quickly -- possibly using his shared outsider status with Trump to his advantage in negotiations. 5. Once a quiet colonial outpost, Malaysia's Penang Island has evolved into a multicultural hub where temples, street art and clan houses meet hip cafes and heritage hotels. Writer and local resident Marco Ferrarese shares how to enjoy the island's rich history, vibrant food scene and lush hill trails. Through the lens This week's top photo pick: South Korea's new President Lee Jae-myung forms a heart shape with his arms as he greets supporters after his inauguration in Seoul on June 4. (Photo by Lee Jin-man/Pool/Reuters) Check out more of our photo coverage here Wishing you a wonderful weekend!