Temba Bavuma's DRS Call Gives Rise To Controversy; Players, Umpires, Commentators Left Surprised
Day 2 of the ongoing 2023-25 World Test Championship final between South Africa and Australia had a couple of controversial moments. Both of them took place during the Proteas' batting at Lord's in London on Thursday. One of them included South Africa captain Temba Bavuma. The right-handed batter was hit on the back pad while playing a back of a length delivery from Australia's Josh Hazlewood. The ball nipped in and hit Bavuma with the umpire raising his finger over an appeal for an LBW. The South Africa captain took his time as he went to David Bedingham at the other end, had a chat with him and then decided to go upstairs.
Prima facie it looked that Bavuma was out but the replay had a different result. While there was a decent gap when the ball passed the bat, UltraEdge showed a spike there, forcing the third umpire to reverse the decision made by the ground umpire.
DRS saved Temba Bavuma pic.twitter.com/7nQu78Gf1w
— Gurlabh Singh (@gurlabhsingh610) June 12, 2025
The Australian players were left in shock. Commentator Ian Smith was also surprised over the decision while Mel Jones too had similar thoughts about it.
"Well that's an interesting one for me, I've got to say. Because it took forever to think about reviewing it. When you feel as if you've got a touch on it you just automatically say 'I'm sorry, I'm reviewing that because I believe my bat has made contact with the ball there'. There was no semblance of that in that discussion. That was so interesting," said Jones.
"This was the slightly controversial one because everything aligned in terms of the LBW shout," she said over another replay.Temba Bavuma's reaction was all about 'do we use the review, was it going to hit'. It didn't feel at all like he had that inside edge," she added.
Appears to be a gap between the bat and ball
For someone who got an inside edge Bavuma looked far from convinced he hit it before review. #WTC2025 #AUSvSA pic.twitter.com/R0nvnQMIr5
— Bernie Coen (@berniecoen) June 12, 2025
Bavuma was clearly out! Clearly some technical glitch on the snickometer. There was clearly no edge!
— Troll cricket unlimitedd (@TUnlimitedd) June 12, 2025
In another controversial moment on the day, Australia spinner Beau Webster's delivery nipped back in and got an inside edge of David Bedingham's bat and nearly stopped close to his pad. As Australia wicketkeeper Alex Carey was moving close to the batter to catch the ball, Bedingham collected the ball, which was in motion and dropped it on the ground. There were a couple of appeals, from Usman Khawaja and Steve Smith. Australia wicketkeeper Carey went ahead with the appeal, pointing out towards an obstruction of field, but the umpires were unconvinced. Australia captain Pat Cummins ended up laughing over the incident.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
NDTV
an hour ago
- NDTV
Yashasvi Jaiswal, KL Rahul Shatter Historic Record In 1st Test vs England, Surpass Sunil Gavaskar-Kris Srikkanth
India's opening pair of Yashasvi Jaiswal and KL Rahul stamped their authority at Headingley with a record-breaking stand, becoming the most successful Indian openers at the venue in Test cricket in the ongoing first Test of the five-match series on Friday. The stylish left-right combination put together 91 runs for the first wicket, surpassing the 64-run mark set by legends Sunil Gavaskar and Kris Srikkanth back in 1986 — a record that stood unchallenged for 39 years. After England captain Ben Stokes opted to bowl first under overcast skies, Jaiswal and Rahul faced a disciplined new-ball attack led by Chris Woakes and Brydon Carse. The Indian openers started cautiously, showing sound judgment outside off and immense patience. As the session wore on, both batters found fluency—Rahul unfurling elegant drives through cover, and Jaiswal playing with a mix of controlled aggression and solid technique. Their partnership of 91 runs was a masterclass in shot selection and temperament, with the pair collecting 16 boundaries, all via classical strokes through the offside. Despite a few testing deliveries—most notably a nasty ribcage blow to Jaiswal from Carse—the duo looked in complete control. For a while, England appeared bereft of ideas, even burning a DRS review on a delivery that pitched comfortably outside leg stump. Just as it seemed India would head to lunch with all ten wickets intact, England roared back in the final six balls of the session to peg the visitors back. Brydon Carse provided the much-needed breakthrough with a wide outswinger that KL Rahul edged to Joe Root at first slip for a composed 42. Then, on debut, Sai Sudharsan lasted just four balls before falling to a leg-side strangle off Ben Stokes—caught behind by Jamie Smith for a duck. Those two quick wickets brought life back into a contest that was rapidly tilting India's way. Despite the wobble, Yashasvi Jaiswal remained unbeaten on 44 at lunch, continuing to look assured after his stellar showing in the previous India-England series w, where he tallied over 700 runs.
First Post
2 hours ago
- First Post
Bavuma, Proteas' WTC Win Rewrites Cricket's Legacy at Lord's First Sports With Rupha Ramani
Bavuma, Proteas' WTC Win Rewrites Cricket's Legacy at Lord's | First Sports With Rupha Ramani | N18G Bavuma, Proteas' WTC Win Rewrites Cricket's Legacy at Lord's | First Sports With Rupha Ramani | N18G South Africa's World Test Championship victory over Australia was more than just a cricketing milestone, it was a powerful symbol of transformation. After 27 years without a major ICC trophy, it was Temba Bavuma, a black captain once mocked for his race and stature — who stood tall at Lord's with the mace in hand. This wasn't just a win; it was the culmination of a journey through discrimination, doubt, and a deeply rooted history. From apartheid-era exclusion to a moment of global sporting redemption, Bavuma's leadership has redefined what representation means in cricket. Rupha Ramani explores the powerful symbolism of South Africa's win, its echo of India's cricketing shift in 2007 under MS Dhoni, and how this championship signals a new era — where cricket isn't just the 'gentleman's game,' but everyone's game. See More
Indian Express
2 hours ago
- Indian Express
Why Temba Bavuma was chosen as captain by Cricket South Africa all those seasons ago
When the World Test Championship came into the FTP in 2019, Enoch Nkwe was at the helm of South Africa team as its team director. He was then demoted as an assistant coach unceremoniously before he quit the post for good. In 2022, he returned as director of cricket overseeing a significant transition in white-ball and red-ball cricket with split coaches. The 42-year-old, gleeful after the Proteas won the WTC beating the mighty Australia, speaks to The Indian Express about the road that South Africa took to become new WTC champions and why Temba Bavuma was chosen as captain. 'It's not the colour, it's the character,' he explains. Excerpts Definitely this is very powerful. This is impactful. We have seen what CSA has done and the impact that he has had as a leader. In the cricketing space, he is now taking the belief to a new level among the kids in the township, who never believed that they can actually play cricket, become batsmen and also captain the country and lead them to becoming world champions. Now all the young kids and especially the ones in disadvantaged areas will get that belief. Even generally the young kids of today, they are going to start looking at this whole thing with a different lens because they can believe that it doesn't matter which background you come from, you have the opportunity and you can do it. It is what Temba has done. He has restored so much faith and belief in the individuals and it just goes to show it is not about colour. It is about the character. You put the right person with the right character in a position to lead the people and inspire the nation, and that is the result you get. He has been great at that. He's been fantastic at that. He did it and continues to do it for Proteas cricket. Q. What made you go with him as a captain? What pulled you towards him? The one thing about Temba is, he has always been a team man. He goes about his business very quietly and always puts the team first. And having worked with him before when I was a coach and also how he has blended well with Shukri I just knew it's gonna work. It's one of those you know… The strong chemistry and the dynamics were good between the two. Shukri has been very supportive of him as well. He has been fantastic through thick and thin. As a team we went through lot of challenges in 2020, 2021 and 2022. He was always the man who came forward and protected the team. He would rather take the punches for the team than letting the team take the punches. He got a lot of criticism and but for me, he stood firm and that's a sign of a great leader. It was just a matter of time he got rewarded in terms of the work that he's put behind all those years and show them the way through the struggles and all the challenges. Q: Winning the WTC has been your target since 2019. After different roles, you have achieved the target. How did you get here? We had a vision then and our thing was always looking at the WTC and the 2023 World Cup and how we need to put a strategy in place to try and win those two majors. Unfortunately, things obviously changed a little bit in between. My roles changed, but the blueprint remained the same. When I came back, it was all about how to take it forward by bringing in some new ideas. We had the WTC 2025 and the 2027 World Cup which we are hosting. When I took the role in 2022, we re-strategized by splitting the coaching role with an eye on 2023 World Cup and the 2025 WTC. We needed different strategy and the ones who we brought ended up producing the best performance by any South African team in the 2023 World Cup and the WTC. In successive white-ball World Cups we saw the team heading in the right direction and in red ball cricket, we had quite a nice generation of players coming through and Shukri Conrad (head coach) did great work. Obviously after the New Zealand tour there was a lot of criticism because we sent a C team for the tour. After that tour, Shukri and myself did re-strategize to find a way to reach the final. And here we are winning 8 of the remaining Tests. From my conversation with Shukri, I felt quite confident we could go all the way, because he had the plans in place. Q: It was also the time you were playing mostly two-match Test series and were losing some of the talents. How concerning was that? Test cricket has remained our one priority and we wanted to make sure that the best players were available for selection for each of those matches. Playing two-match series was a concern, but we knew it the moment the FTP came out. We wanted to maximise it and at the same time the SA20 was also important for us and outside of Test cricket, we played India A and West Indies A which helped us bridge the gap and make sure it keeps going forward. Shukri also ensured that he kept driving the belief in the Test team and within the individuals. I believe that was extraordinary because we had batsmen making huge scores in the journey. The character of the team was the biggest thing for me. It was powerful… even with the ball, we had a complete team performance where everyone bought into the plan and found ways to win games. It was evident right through. By the time we played Sri Lanka and Pakistan at home, the confidence was high. Q: Also does playing just two-match series in the new cycle help you retain the best talents? You don't have much Test cricket, so they can play the T20 leagues around as well? We signed off the FTP in 2022 so we knew the next four years this is what it looks like. For us, it was like how do we make this work. We know that from one cycle of the WTC to the next cycle there's an amount of games we are having and we're going to make do with it and see how we best manage our players. In this situation I guess it might help, we don't know. It might help because there's so much cricket being played, but we want to try and obviously better the Test cricket content in the next cycle after 2027 so that we play more Tests. Hence we're negotiating to improve the tally in the next cycle. But we have got 14 Tests and we are going to do our best to try and win as many as possible and be in the finals again and retain the championship. Q: Will the planned Test match fund help Cricket South Africa? From our point of view, there are always talks of how do we improve our Test cricket and bring in more three or four-match Test series. That should be great for global cricket as well because more the Test cricket, the better the sport is. It is a spin off because the best T20 cricketers in the last 15 years have all been great at Test cricket as well. If it is stronger, cricket is stronger across formats. We saw it at Lord's, how much people love it. It was exciting and that's what we want. Yes, the WTC format can be improved, and I don't know what structure it can be, but there are definite encouraging signs to build on. I'm hoping that you know there will be even a much more improved structure, come the next cycle and we can even play more Test cricket. Q: Making Temba Bavuma the captain wasn't a popular choice when CSA made the appointment. With the WTC win, he has left an undeniable footprint in South Africa's history. How much does it mean to the Black community? Definitely this is very powerful. This is impactful. We have seen what CSA has done and the impact that he has had as a leader. In the cricketing space, he is now taking the belief to a new level among the kids in the township, who never believed that they can actually play cricket, become batsmen and also captain the country and lead them to becoming world champions. Now all the young kids and especially the ones in disadvantaged areas will get that belief. Even generally the young kids of today, they are going to start looking at this whole thing with a different lens because they can believe that it doesn't matter which background you come from, you have the opportunity and you can do it. It is what Temba has done. He has restored so much faith and belief in the individuals and it just goes to show it is not about colour. It is about the character. You put the right person with the right character in a position to lead the people and inspire the nation, and that is the result you get. He has been great at that. He's been fantastic at that. He did it and continues to do it for Proteas cricket. Q What made you go with him as a captain? What pulled you towards him? The one thing about Temba is, he has always been a team man. He goes about his business very quietly and always puts the team first. And having worked with him before when I was a coach and also how he has blended well with Shukri I just knew it's gonna work. It's one of those you know… The strong chemistry and the dynamics were good between the two. Shukri has been very supportive of him as well. He has been fantastic through thick and thin. As a team we went through lot of challenges in 2020, 2021 and 2022. He was always the man who came forward and protected the team. He would rather take the punches for the team than letting the team take the punches. He got a lot of criticism and but for me, he stood firm and that's a sign of a great leader. It was just a matter of time he got rewarded in terms of the work that he's put behind all those years and show them the way through the struggles and all the challenges. Q: We saw Heinrich Klaasen announce his retirement recently with a home World Cup just two years away. At their high point, we see good talents suddenly exiting the scene by ignoring central contracts. How concerning is this? It's always going to be disappointing when players of such caliber leave the national team or not sign the national contract. We are always open to try and accommodate. Some of them are happy to just be freelancers but be available for the national team. Some of them retire completely from the game. But one thing we're doing now is the next best talent that we keep finding from our school system and inter-provincial system — which we are quite blessed with — we need to prepare them to transition up. So we are building a stronger feeder system, where even if an international player moves on, there is another player who is ready to step up. That's been our focus in the last three years because we did expect certain players at certain times to be leaving the national team or becoming freelancers. That's the reality of the new world. Since we are blessed with good talents which are coming through, we need to nurture them and empower them to make sure they are ready for Proteas.
