The Irish Times view on Leaving Cert reforms: AI must be taken seriously
The Government and teachers' unions may be on a collision course over the introduction of major reforms to the
Leaving Certificate
later this year.
The changes, due to be introduced for all students entering the senior cycle this September, will see nine new or revised subjects incorporating research projects worth 40 per cent of overall marks, a radical shift from the traditional reliance on written end-of-year exams.
Secondary teachers' unions will conduct ballots in the coming weeks on whether to accept the package proposed by the Government to ease the introduction of the reforms. These include pay increases, permanent contracts for new teachers and the creation of additional middle-management positions.
The
Teachers' Union of Ireland
has recommended acceptance, but the
Association of Secondary Teachers Ireland
has made no recommendation. Further votes on industrial action are expected should the proposals be rejected.
READ MORE
These reforms have long been sought by educationalists who believe the current Leaving Cert is too rigid, places excessive pressure on students and encourages rote learning rather than critical thinking. Some supporters of the changes will undoubtedly be frustrated that the concerns expressed by the unions might lead to delays.
There is merit, however, to some of the criticisms of the timing and manner in which the reforms are being introduced.
Particular concern centres on use by students of
artificial intelligence
(AI). Generative AI tools already produce work that achieves high grades at postgraduate level. AI detection tools are unreliable and a thriving market has sprung up for software that makes detection impossible.
It would be a tragic irony if reforms that are supposed to encourage individual development and independent thinking were to be undermined by a technology that bypasses exactly those human qualities. Minister for Education
Helen McEntee
should take teachers' concern seriously and engage further with them on the issue.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
3 hours ago
- Irish Times
The Irish Times view on planning in Ireland: vital clarity must be restored
An Coimisiún Pleanála was quietly ushered into existence last week. The Minster for Housing, James Browne, formally established the body which has taken of the role of An Bord Pleanála, the previous appeals body for planning applications. It had lost the confidence of the public and the previous government amidst serious governance failures and lengthy planning delays. The establishment of the new commission comes as a worrying sense of drift envelopes this Government's efforts to address the seemingly intractable shortage of housing. The lengthy gestation of the new body is in itself evidence of a seeming lack of urgency. The Planning and Development Bill which created it was was first brought before the Dáil in November 2023, but was only passed by the Oireachtas last October. That was an inexcusably long time, even allowing for committee debate. It took another six months for the minster to commence the section relating to the planning commission. Many other measures remain to be commenced. The costs of such delay are clear for all to see. The latest figures from the Central Statistics Office - published last Friday - show that residential construction activity is falling. READ MORE Paul Reid, a former head of both Fingal County Council and the Health Service Executive has been appointed chairman of the governing body of the new commission. He would seem well qualified to meet the challenges of leading the new body. The biggest is restoring public, political and industry confidence in the speed and clarity of the planning process which rightly carries much of the blame for the housing shortage. The new statutory targets that have now been set for decisions on planning cases including critical infrastructure projects for transport, water, grid and energy as well large-scale residential developments , need to be met. For that to happen the new body will have to get the resources it needs when it needs them. If it doesn't, then the new commission risks being seen as little more than old wine in a new bottle.
Irish Times
4 hours ago
- Irish Times
Anti-racism and anti-immigration demonstrations held in Dublin city
An anti-racism rally and an anti- immigration demonstration were held in Dublin city on Sunday. O'Connell Bridge was closed for a time on Sunday afternoon as gardaí erected extensive barriers to separate the two crowds. The United Against Racism rally began at the Central Plaza on Dame Street, marching through the city to O'Connell Bridge at about 2pm. Several protesters carried signs saying: 'Blame the Government, not migrants'; and: 'Dublin stands against racism'. They also chanted: 'Say it loud, say it clear, refugees are welcome here.' READ MORE The anti-immigration protest marched down O'Connell Street and turned left at O'Connell bridge before continuing along the quays. Participants from both sides shouted and gestured towards each other from across the empty space between the barriers created by gardaí. At one point, the anti-racism rally chanted at the anti-immigration group: 'You say protect women, that's a lie' and referenced a photo being carried by one person of MMA fighter Conor McGregor , who lost a civil trial where a Dublin woman accused him of raping her in a Dublin hotel. A mock-up photograph depicts MMA fighter Conor McGregor alongside Russian and US leaders Vladimir Putin and Donald Trump. Photograph: Collins Photos [ 'I know what happened in that room': the full story of the Conor McGregor case Opens in new window ] The anti-immigration group, which was the larger of the two, was thick with large Tricolour flags. 'Whose streets? Our streets' some sang. Several people were seen wearing 'Make Ireland Great Again' green caps and holding US and Donald Trump banners, and some signs critical of RTÉ. A United Against Racism demonstration on Dame Street, Dublin. Photograph: Stephen Collins/Collins Photos There was an extensive Garda presence at the location where the two protest groups were due to cross paths. The Garda Mounted Support Unit, the Public Order Unit, and Garda members from outside the Dublin Metropolitan Region were in attendance. – PA
Irish Times
5 hours ago
- Irish Times
Leo Varadkar says politicians should not censor artists following Keir Starmer Kneecap remark
Former taoiseach Leo Varadkar has said politicians should not try to censor artists after British prime minister Keir Starmer described Kneecap's forthcoming performance at the Glastonbury festival as inappropriate. Kneecap member Liam Óg Ó hAnnaidh, whose stage name is Mo Chara, appeared in court on Wednesday charged, under UK anti-terrorism legislation, with showing support for a proscribed organisation. It was alleged he draped himself in a Hizbullah flag at a London gig last November and shouted 'up Hamas, up Hizbullah', referring to the Palestinian and Lebanese militant groups respectively. In an interview with The Sun, Mr Starmer said he did not think the Belfast rap trio should perform at Glastonbury. READ MORE 'I think we need to come down really clearly on this. This is about the threats that shouldn't be made, I won't say too much because there's a court case on, but I don't think that's appropriate,' he said. It comes after Conservative Party leader Kemi Badenoch said on X that she thought the BBC 'should not be showing' Kneecap's performance at the festival next week. Kneecap's official Instagram page shared a screenshot of the article containing Mr Starmer's comments, stating that 'arming a fu*king genocide' was what's 'not appropriate'. In a comment underneath the post, Mr Varadkar said he had thought the comment from Mr Starmer was a 'gag'. '[I] no longer hold office nor have any mandate so my views don't count for so much anymore. I get that. But I really thought this was some sort of gag. It's the role of artists to be avant guarde, inappropriate, challenging, disruptive - from James Joyce to Sex Pistols and Playboy,' he said. [ Fans rally behind Kneecap after London court appearance: 'If you're supporting Ireland, you're supporting Kneecap' Opens in new window ] 'Politicians really should not try to censor this. If an offence was committed, let the courts decide. In the meantime, the rule of law says the accused is innocent until proven guilty.' Mr Ó hAnnaidh was released on unconditional bail until his next hearing on August 20th. He and his bandmates – Naoise Ó Cairealláin, and JJ Ó Dochartaigh - arrived at the central London court to a scrum of hundreds of supporters who cheered as their vehicle pulled up outside it. The band were wearing 'Free Mo Chara' T-shirts as they arrived. Following the hearing, the rapper said: 'For anybody going to Glastonbury, you can see us there at 4pm on the Saturday. 'If you can't be there we'll be on the BBC, if anybody watches the BBC. We'll be at Wembley in September.' - Additional reporting Agencies
