Google suffers blow at EU's top court over record €4.12bn competition fine
Google's
hopes of overturning a record EU competition fine were dealt a severe blow on Thursday, after an adviser to Europe's top court agreed with Brussels regulators that the tech giant had used its Android mobile phone operating system to squash rivals.
Juliane Kokott, advocate-general of the European Court of Justice, the EU's highest court, said that a €4.12 billion fine issued against the US company should be upheld.
While not legally binding, the majority of such opinions are followed by the ECJ. A ruling by the court is expected in the coming months.
'Google held a dominant position in several markets of the Android ecosystem and thus benefited from network effects that enabled it to ensure that users used Google Search,' said Kokott. 'As a result, Google obtained access to data that enabled it to turn to improve its service.'
READ MORE
The win provides a boost to the European Commission, which is seeking to enforce tough new rules aimed at holding the world's largest tech companies to account.
The Android case dates back to 2018, when the EU accused Google of imposing illegal restrictions on Android device makers and mobile network operators 'to cement its dominant position' in internet search.
Google said it was 'disappointed' with the opinion. 'Android has created more choice for everyone and supports thousands of successful businesses in Europe and around the world,' it added.
The European Commission declined to comment.
The initial fine issued by the European Commission was €4.34 billion. When Google challenged that penalty, the General Court in 2022 ruled mostly in favour of Brussels' decision but reduced it slightly to €4.12 billion, a decision the Big Tech group also appealed against.
Kokott on Thursday advised the ECJ to dismiss Google's appeal, stating that 'the legal arguments put forward by Google are ineffective'.
The fine was part of a trio of cases against Alphabet-owned Google, which has seen regulators fine the company a total of €8 billion over the past decade.
The EU's top court has already backed the bloc's decision to fine the tech giant €2.42 billion for favouring its own comparison shopping service ahead of rivals, which can no longer be appealed against.
But Google did win its appeal against a €1.5 billion fine from 2019 for blocking competitors in the online advertising market, which the General Court annulled last year.
Separately, the EU is wrapping up its investigation into Google's online advertising technology, which it launched in 2023. – Copyright The Financial Times Limited 2025
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
2 hours ago
- Irish Times
Dublin airport operator warned over passenger cap breach
Dublin Airport operator DAA has been issued with an enforcement order by Fingal County Council for breaching the 32 million annual passenger limit, despite a High Court suspension of the cap. An Bord Pleanála imposed the limit on airport's capacity in 2007 as a condition of allowing it add a second terminal. The move was meant to allay fears over traffic jams on roads to and from the airport, which have since been upgraded. State company DAA applied to the council for permission to increase the cap to 36 million and 40 million in separate applications, but has yet to receive a decision from the planning authority. However, in April the High Court effectively suspended the passenger cap pending the outcome of a legal challenge relating to the limit taken last year by Irish airlines Ryanair and Aer Lingus, and Airlines for America, which represents US and Canadian carriers. READ MORE The cap was breached last year when 33.3 million passengers came through the airport. The council has now issued DAA with an enforcement notice which allows a two-year period to comply with the passenger capacity conditions. [ Aviation regulator drops measure from winter travel plan Opens in new window ] 'The two-year period provides an opportunity for DAA to progress their planning applications to increase passenger capacity at Dublin Airport or take such other steps as they consider appropriate to achieve compliance,' the council said. In response to complaints received that the conditions were breached in 2023 and 2024, the council's enforcement unit initiated a formal investigation to assess compliance. 'A warning letter was issued to DAA, providing them with an opportunity to respond, which they did,' the council said. 'Fingal County Council acknowledges the operational complexities presented. However, the information submitted by DAA does not constitute sufficient grounds to prevent further action. The investigation has determined that a breach of the relevant planning conditions has occurred and remains ongoing.' A DAA spokesman described the issuing of the enforcement notice as a 'sorry indictment' of the planning system. 'The fact that Fingal County Council is sending us an enforcement notice regarding 32 million passengers when passenger numbers will be north of 36 million this year and heading towards 40 million before the end of the decade is a sorry indictment of the mess that is the Irish planning system, particularly when it comes to the most vital piece of transport infrastructure on this island,' he said. DAA said that until the 'broken' system was overhauled the airport was effectively 'hamstrung' and unable to grow Ireland's connectivity. It has called for a complete scrapping of the passenger limit and for the airport to be classified as strategic infrastructure, placing relevant decisions in the hands of a national planning body and not a local authority. 'When it took up office, the Government committed to acting speedily to identify and implement a legislative solution that would remove the passenger cap from Dublin Airport,' the DAA spokesman said. 'The Minister has since also said he will bring forward legislation to solve the cap issue, dispel uncertainty and maintain connectivity for Ireland – and this can't happen quickly enough.' Minister for Transport Darragh O'Brien last month said he hoped forthcoming legislation could bring an end to the dispute.
Irish Times
4 hours ago
- Irish Times
Former Ires activist Vision to lose one board nominee as it cuts stake below 3%
Ires Reit shareholder Vision Capital, which secured board seats for two nominees last year to resolve a standoff with the company, is on track to see one of those representatives step down after it reduced its holding in the business below 3 per cent. Toronto-based Vision, led by Jeff Olin, started a year-long campaign in April 2023 for a sale or break-up of Ireland's largest private apartments owner . It reached a truce 14 months ago that resulted in two candidates it put forward joining the Dublin-listed company's board. Vision owned about 5 per cent of the stock at the time. The two directors were one-time chief operating officer of Canada's CIBC Bank Richard Nesbitt and Amy Freedman, an investment banker turned corporate consultant. They were part of a unanimous board conclusion last August, following a strategic review, that a sale or break-up of the company would not be in investors' best interests. Vision subsequently cut its stake in Ires, which is led by chief executive Eddie Byrne . Last September, its shareholding fell below 4 per cent and it reduced its holding further on Tuesday to 2.96 per cent, according to stock exchange filings. READ MORE The standstill agreement between Ires and Vision last year provides that Ms Freedman would step down from the board if the investment firm's stake were to fall below 3 per cent. Shares in Ires, which has 3,734 residential units in Dublin, have rebounded almost 16 per cent so far this year to €1.05, driven by falling European Central Bank (ECB) interest rates which have boosted investor appetite for property stocks. Still, the stock has pulled back by about 5 per cent from highs reached earlier this month as investors digest the Government's planned reform of rent controls . A planned new nationwide control system – set to fully kick in from March 2026 – would see rent increases for tenancies capped in most cases by inflation or a maximum cap of 2 per cent. However, landlords would be able to reset rents at the going market rate when a tenant leaves. Smaller landlords with three or fewer units will have to offer rolling six-year tenancies, while large ones will not be able to evict a tenant who has complied with their obligations except in very limited circumstances. Rent control for new apartments constructed following enactment of the legislation would be linked to inflation without the 2 per cent cap. This, the Government said, should 'provide certainty, clarity and encourage investment'.
Irish Times
4 hours ago
- Irish Times
Irish pharma exports drive euro zone trade in first quarter
Irish pharma exports were the main driver of euro zone exports in the first quarter, according to the European Central Bank (ECB). In its latest economic bulletin, the Frankfurt-based central bank said exports of euro area goods 'rose substantially' – by 4.9 per cent – in the first three months of the year on the back of 'US tariff-related front-loading'. 'This was driven chiefly by pharmaceutical exports, mainly from Ireland and via Switzerland, but also from Germany, France and Italy,' it said. Irish good exports rose by 64 per cent to €88.4 billion in the first quarter as companies fast-tracked product into the US to avoid incoming tariffs. READ MORE The ECB, however, warned that the export boom may be short-lived. [ Irish exports surged ahead of Trump's 'liberation day' tariffs Opens in new window ] 'While more front-loading may take place in the coming months, higher tariffs, policy uncertainty and the appreciation of the euro are expected to cause headwinds for export volumes further ahead,' it said. It also warned that on the import side, 'the appreciation of the euro and trade deflection resulting from US-China trade tensions' were likely to dampen import prices. The stronger euro has helped bring down inflation quicker than expected. Headline inflation is now set to average 2 per cent this year, 1.6 per cent in 2026 and 2 per cent in 2027, it said. In its report, the ECB warned the economic outlook for the bloc was 'clouded by trade tensions and elevated global uncertainty'. For 2025 as a whole, these effects are seen to be partly compensated by stronger than expected economic activity in the first quarter. In the medium term, economic activity will be supported by recently announced fiscal measures, including Germany's €1 trillion military and infrastructure investment plan. US president Donald Trump has threatened to impose 50 per cent tariffs on imports from the EU but has put a stay on the measure until July 9th to allow for talks. [ Von der Leyen: EU needs until July 9th to reach trade deal with US Opens in new window ] 'Overall, the conditions remain in place for euro area GDP growth to strengthen over the projection horizon,' the ECB said. 'In particular, rising real wages and employment, less restrictive financing conditions – mainly reflecting recent monetary policy decisions – and a rebound in foreign demand in the later part of the projection horizon should all support a gradual recovery.' The bank noted that trade tensions and the stronger exchange rate have resulted in a downward revision to growth for 2026, while growth is unrevised for 2027. It sees GDP growth across the bloc averaging 0.9 per cent in 2025, 1.1 per cent in 2026 and 1.3 per cent in 2027. On the US economy, the ECB said the growth outlook has deteriorated. 'Real GDP turned slightly negative in the first quarter of 2025, as the front-loading of imports resulted in a large negative contribution from net trade. 'At the same time, domestic demand remained relatively solid; it is, however, expected to slow down as the impact of tariffs take hold,' it said, noting that tariffs are projected to increase the cost of imported goods, 'which will likely spill over to domestic prices'.
