A reservoir of gold lies hidden in Earth's core. Scientists say it's leaking
By
Jacopo Prisco
, CNN
Gold and other precious metals deep beneath the Earth eventually make their way up to the surface during the formation of volcanic islands, a study suggests.
Photo:
123rf
Gold and other precious metals are leaking from Earth's core into the layers above, eventually making their way up to the surface during the formation of volcanic islands like Hawaii, a new study suggests.
The theory results from a three-year analysis of Hawaii's basaltic rocks, which originally formed from plumes of magma, or molten rock, rising from the ocean floor. Clues in the form of heavy metals found in the volcanic rocks could confirm a suspicion long held by geologists - that Earth's molten core is not isolated but likely bleeds into the rocky mantle, the layer between the planet's thin crust and the core.
"About 40 years ago, people first came up with the theory that maybe the core is losing some material into the mantle, but the signals we got so far were really ambiguous," said Nils Messling, a geochemist at the University of Göttingen in Germany and lead author of the report, published 21 May in the journal
Nature
.
"Now, in my opinion, we have the first very strong evidence that some of the core is actually ending up in the mantle."
Scientists already knew that most of the gold on the planet - more than 99.95 percent, according to Messling - lies hidden in the molten core, along with other heavy elements such as platinum.
Basalt sampled from a drill core section from the Kilauea Iki lava lake, which erupted in 1959, is shown. The Hawaiian lava rock contains a small trace of Earth's core, the analysis found.
Photo:
Supplied / CNN / Nils Messling
As meteorites bombarded one another in Earth's early history, a reservoir of these precious metals developed when the core formed about 4.5 billion years ago.
But this study suggests that at least a tiny amount of that gold has escaped to the surface, raising the fascinating prospect that, if the leaking continues, more and more of this precious metal could travel from the centre of Earth to the crust in the future.
"Our findings not only show that the Earth's core is not as isolated as previously assumed. We can now also prove that huge volumes of super-heated mantle material - several hundreds of quadrillion metric tonnes of rock - originate at the core-mantle boundary and rise to the Earth's surface to form ocean islands like Hawaii," said study coauthor Matthias Willbold, a professor at the University of Göttingen, in a statement.
To find evidence of this core-mantle interaction, Messling and his coauthors obtained some samples of Hawaiian volcanic rocks from the Smithsonian Institution in Washington, DC.
The research team extracts precious metals from samples of Hawaii's volcanic rock.
Photo:
Supplied / CNN / Nils Messling
"Some were taken by a submarine, from a deep sea volcano, but [otherwise] it's basically just very ordinary-looking basaltic rock, very unassuming, that you would find anywhere on Hawaii," he said.
"We started with half a kilogram of rock, we crushed it into a powder, and then we melted it in the oven with some different chemicals, to end up with a sample in liquid form."
From that sample, the team extracted all the elements in the
platinum group
, which includes platinum itself as well as the lesser-known rhodium, palladium, iridium, osmium and ruthenium. The scientists then focused on ruthenium, a silver-grey metal about as rare in Earth's crust as gold.
"The mantle has almost no ruthenium in it," Messling said.
"It's one of the rarest elements on Earth. But Earth is basically made of meteorites that crashed together, and meteorites [contain] ruthenium, which went into the core when the core formed. So the mantle has next to no ruthenium, and the core has all of the ruthenium. The same with gold and platinum."
Earth's core has two layers. A hot, solid metal sphere of iron and nickel is roughly 70 percent the size of the moon, with a radius of about 1221km. A liquid metal outer core is about 2253km thick and extends to about 2897km below the surface, or right up to the mantle.
Photo:
123rf
In contrast, the mantle, which lies between the planet's outer crust and the molten core, is 2897km of mostly solid rock.
To determine whether the extracted ruthenium was originally from the core and not the mantle, the team looked at a specific isotope, or type, of ruthenium that was likely more abundant in Earth's early building materials during the time the core formed billions of years ago.
"The vast majority of gold and other precious metals like platinum were likely delivered by massive meteorite impacts during the final stages of Earth's formation - a process known as late accretion," said Pedro Waterton, an assistant professor of geochemistry at the University of Copenhagen in Denmark who was not involved in the study.
The presence of the ruthenium isotope in the basalt samples indicates that at least some of the rock was formed from material coming from the molten metallic core.
That's because there is consensus, Messling said, that the material that coalesced during the early stages of Earth's formation does not exist in the meteorite record anymore.
He added that the isotope signature in rocks from hotspot volcanoes like the ones in Hawaii is entirely different from any other known rock or meteorite.
In other words, the ruthenium isotope Messling found was locked away in the core billions of years ago, so detecting the isotope in volcanic rocks today suggests it comes from the core.
"It's quite a novel and difficult method," Messling said.
"We managed to measure ruthenium in rocks that have next to no ruthenium in them. In half a kilo of rock, it was less than milligrams - a needle in a planet-sized haystack! That's quite exciting - for a geochemist, at least. It was a long but very exciting process."
So what's the connection with gold? It's chemically similar to ruthenium, Messling said, so if the core is leaking ruthenium, it is also leaking gold in similar quantities.
This would be a "minuscule" amount, however. And even if scientists wanted to extract gold directly from the source, the core-mantle boundary, that's much farther down than current technology could drill.
In fact, it's about 236 times deeper than the deepest bore ever drilled - the
Kola Superdeep Borehole
in Russia, which reaches a depth of 12.3km.
The ruthenium isotope signature in rocks from hotspot volcanoes like the ones in Hawaii is entirely different from any other rock or meteorite on record, according to lead study author Nils Messling. geochemist at the University of Göttingen.
Photo:
Supplied / CNN / Nils Messling
Proof that the core isn't isolated is particularly thrilling because the core and the mantle shouldn't interact at all, Messling said.
"Their density is too different, like oil and water, so technically they shouldn't mix. And we still don't have a good mechanism to explain why they do. We don't really know much about the core at all," he said.
The Hawaiian rock samples suggest that the leaking process takes between 500 million and 1 billion years to complete, Messling said.
"It's something that has occurred a while ago, and we suspect that it probably has been going on forever, and it's probably still occurring now," he explained.
According to Messling, if the leaking of precious metals is an ongoing process, it could be that at least some of the gold humans have mined may have come from the core even if the quantity of core material in a single rock is negligible and that the world's supply of gold seems to be replenishing.
"It's a very interesting idea that, although this process is tiny and has zero effect if you look at just one island, if you scale it up to 4.5 billion years it could be that it changes the composition of the Earth," he said.
Researchers who were not involved in the study expressed positive views on the findings.
"We know that the Earth was built from different generations of meteoritic material that were added progressively to the growing planet, and that precious metals from the earliest generations of meteorite material became concentrated into our planet's core while metals from meteorites added in the final stages of the Earth's growth became stranded in our planet's mantle," said Helen Williams, a professor of geochemistry and planetary science at the University of Cambridge in the United Kingdom.
The study, she added, confirms that the mantle plumes - rising jets of molten rock coming from the core-mantle boundary that create hot spots like Hawaii - do indeed contain material somehow derived from Earth's metallic core, said Williams, adding that the result was "exciting."
Jesse Reimink, an associate professor of geosciences at Pennsylvania State University, agrees.
"This is a very old debate, and new data over the past 10 or so years has reinvigorated the possibility that the core was chemically 'leaking' into the mantle over time," he said.
"This study really does seem to nail the conclusion - the core does contribute some material to the mantle."
The latest research also strengthens the case made in
previous work
that some mantle plumes incorporate material from Earth's core, said the University of Copenhagen's Waterton.
Does that also mean some of the gold in Earth's crust is originally from the core?
"Yes, but probably only a very small amount," he said.
-
CNN
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
21 hours ago
- RNZ News
Experimental new drug results in up to 24pct weight loss, comes in a pill
By Deena Beasley , Reuters The full trial results were presented at the annual meeting of the American Diabetes Association in Chicago and published in the Lancet medical journal. Photo: 123rf Novo Nordisk on Friday (local time) said full results from early-stage trials show that its experimental drug, amycretin, helped overweight and obese adults lose up to 24 percent of their weight as the Danish company readies for late-stage studies to start next year. The company said side effects of the drug, tested as both a weekly injection and a daily pill, were mostly gastrointestinal with rates similar to other recent weight loss drugs. The [ full trial results[ were presented at the annual meeting of the American Diabetes Association in Chicago and published in the Lancet medical journal. Novo's head of development Martin Holst Lange said the Phase 3 amycretin program starting in 2026 will run "for a couple of years" after which the regulatory review process could start. The company earlier this month said it planned to start late-stage trials of the drug in the first quarter of 2026 after previously announcing the early-stage trial results. Amycretin has a dual-mode action. Like Novo's popular weight-loss drug Wegovy, it mimics the gut hormone GLP-1, but also targets receptors for a hunger-suppressing pancreatic hormone called amylin. Trial results showed that 20-milligram weekly injections of the drug helped overweight or obese patients without diabetes lose 22 percent of their weight over 36 weeks, with a 60-mg dose resulting in 24.3 percent weight loss. In the Phase 1 study of once-daily oral amycretin, patients received increasing doses, ranging from 3 mg to a final dose of 100 mg. Patients who took 50 mg of amycretin at the end of the 12-week trial reduced body weight by 10.4 percent on average, while those taking the maximum dose lost 13.1 percent of their weight, the company said. Novo said the weight loss did not plateau, suggesting that longer treatment could lead to greater weight loss. In a Lancet commentary, researchers not involved in the amycretin studies said that "while additional weight loss is welcome and helpful, our evolving concept of obesity management has now shifted towards an emphasis on the reduction of the risks and burdens of cardiovascular disease and other comorbidities". Commentators Tricia Tan, professor of metabolic medicine and endocrinology at Imperial College London, and endocrinologist Dr Bernard Khoo, said studies directly comparing GLP-1 drugs like Novo's Ozempic to drugs like amycretin will be needed to definitively establish their added value and place in obesity management. - Reuters
RNZ News
2 days ago
- RNZ News
Elon Musk's SpaceX rockets keep blowing up at worst possible time
By Hadas Gold , CNN Another SpaceX Starship goes up in flames. Photo: NASASpaceflight Analysis: As Elon Musk returns his focus to his businesses, one of his most important companies just had another setback: a SpaceX Starship rocket exploded in an immense fireball on Wednesday during a routine ground test. The explosion marks the fourth failure in a row for SpaceX's Starship, all while Musk's other companies and his personal brand struggle to recover after his foray into politics. Starship is supposed to help reach NASA's goal of bringing American astronauts back to the moon by 2027: The US space agency is paying SpaceX up to about US$4 billion for the mission. Although SpaceX has said that the last three launches before Wednesday's explosions were successful in testing some elements, all ended in mid-flight failures. SpaceX has long made the case that failures during the testing and development phase are not the harbingers of disaster they may seem. The company embraces a design philosophy called "rapid iterative development" that emphasises building relatively low-cost prototypes and launching frequent test flights. SpaceX believes the approach allows the company to hash out rocket designs faster and at cheaper price points than relying on slower, more methodical engineering approaches that can guarantee a vehicle's success. But the very fiery Starship explosion comes as Musk has been trying to restore his reputation as he returned to focus on his businesses after a controversial stint in the Trump administration. After several months as a top White House adviser and leading the Department of government Efficiency, Musk is now taking a step back from full-time government work refocusing his time on his companies, including Tesla, which has struggled in part as a result of Musk's alliance with the Trump administration. Upon his return, Musk has sought to promote an image of safety and reliability at Tesla, which is aiming to launch its driverless robotaxis in Austin on Sunday - although the initial phase is expected to be limited to less than two dozen cars, and Musk has warned the date could shift. But before the launch, a group of Texas lawmakers have asked Tesla to delay the rollout of its robotaxi service until September, citing a new law on autonomous driving set to take effect. And Tesla's share price slipped this week, before recovering somewhat, following a report from Business Insider that the company plans to pause production on Cybertruck and Model Y lines for a week at its Austin factory for maintenance, the third such shutdown this year. And in Europe, where Tesla sales have been plunging, Chinese car maker BYD sold more pure battery electric vehicles over Tesla in Europe for the first time, according to a report from JATO , an automotive market research firm. Elon Musk Photo: AFP Musk also has his work cut out for him at his AI company, xAI. Bloomberg reported the company "is burning through US$1 billion a month" as the cost of building out its AI model "races ahead of the limited revenues." Musk brushed off the report. "Bloomberg is talking nonsense," he posted on X in response. They don't. Also, Bloomberg is talking nonsense. Musk also publicly disputed his own AI chatbot Grok, when it posted a fact check about politically motivated violence, noting that "Since 2016, data suggests right-wing political violence has been more frequent and deadly." That response lines up with most publicly available data. But Musk didn't agree. "Major fail, as this is objectively false. Grok is parroting legacy media. Working on it." he posted . Musk seems to be brushing off the setbacks, especially with SpaceX. He said last month that he hoped Starship would make its inaugural flight to Mars by the end of next year - a target that looks increasingly unlikely to be met. "Just a scratch," he posted after Starship's explosion before posting "RIP Ship 36" and memes. When a user asked Musk's chatbot Grok why Musk was posting memes, Grok responded "The timing suggests it's likely a humorous comment on the SpaceX Starship explosion that occurred on June 18, rather than targeting a specific person. Musk often uses memes to downplay such setbacks." Musk responded with a bullseye emoji. -CNN
RNZ News
3 days ago
- RNZ News
US Fed keeps interest rates unchanged in face of Trump criticism
Fed chair Jerome Powell told reporters he wants to wait a few months to see how tariffs affect inflation, spending and hiring. Photo: SAUL LOEB / AFP The US Federal Reserve held interest rates steady for a fourth consecutive meeting on Wednesday, forecasting higher inflation and cooler growth this year as President Donald Trump's tariffs begin to take hold and geopolitical uncertainty swirls . Fed chair Jerome Powell told reporters the central bank would make better decisions if it waited a few months to understand how tariffs impact inflation, spending and hiring, in a sign that the next rate adjustment could take some time to materialise. For now, he expects to learn more "over the summer," while officials appear increasingly divided on whether they can cut interest rates at all in 2025. The Fed kept the benchmark lending rate at a range between 4.25 percent and 4.50 percent at the end of its two-day meeting, with officials pencilling in two rate reductions this year, similar to earlier projections. But there was growing divergence among Fed officials participating in the meeting, with a smaller majority expecting the central bank to lower rates at least twice. Donald Trump's imposition of tariffs is being cited as a reason for the US Fed to keep interest rates unchanged. Photo: AFP / Brendan Smialowski The Fed's decision is likely to draw the ire of Trump, who has repeatedly pressured the independent central bank for rate cuts and on Wednesday called Powell "stupid" for not slashing rates more quickly. "We have a stupid person, frankly, at the Fed," Trump said, hours before the bank was due to release its policy decision. "We have no inflation, we have only success, and I'd like to see interest rates get down," he added, speaking at the White House. "Maybe I should go to the Fed. Am I allowed to appoint myself?" The Fed said in a statement that "uncertainty about the economic outlook has diminished but remains elevated." The central bank also cut its expectations for economic growth this year and raised its inflation and unemployment forecasts, in its first updated projections since Trump in April unleashed sweeping 10 percent tariffs on almost all trading partners. "Increases in tariffs this year are likely to push up prices and weigh on economic activity," Powell said. Avoiding a more persistent impact depends on the size of levies' effects, how long it takes for them to pass through to prices, and keeping expectations anchored, he added. Powell maintained that the Fed was "well-positioned to wait to learn more" before considering changes to interest rates. "Because the economy is still solid, we can take the time to actually see what's going to happen," Powell said. "We'll make smarter and better decisions if we just wait a couple of months." The Fed's call was in line with analysts' expectations. As officials anticipate more clarity on the impact associated with higher tariffs over the summer, "financial markets are not expecting any movement in rates prior to September", said KPMG chief economist Diane Swonk. Major US indexes ended little-changed on Wednesday. Ryan Sweet, chief US economist at Oxford Economics, said the Fed would want evidence that inflation was headed back to its two percent target "before sounding all clear". "Pre-emptive rate cuts don't appear to be on the table, implying the bar is high for the central bank to cut in July," Sweet said. Swonk said however "there is a very strong argument that absent the tariff-induced inflation, the Fed would be cutting rates now," noting that the labour market was slowing. On Wednesday, the Fed cut its expectations for 2025 economic growth to 1.4 percent from its March projection of 1.7 percent. It also raised its inflation forecast to 3.0 percent and that of the unemployment rate to 4.5 percent. Asked about conflict in the Middle East as a clash between Israel and Iran heats up, Powell said that although it was possible to see higher energy prices, these "don't generally tend to have lasting effects on inflation". Trump has pointed to benign US inflation in arguing for cuts. More recently, he cast such a move as a way for the country to "pay much less interest on debt coming due", overlooking the fact that lower interest rates usually raise consumer prices. Powell has maintained that the Fed's rate-setting committee would make its decisions solely on objective and non-political analysis. -AFP
