How is Tesla expected to remotely control its robotaxis, and what are its limitations?
Tesla is expected to tiptoe into its long-awaited robotaxi service in Austin, Texas, as soon as Sunday with about 10 of its Model Y SUVs that will operate within strict limits. CEO Elon Musk has said the company is being 'super paranoid' about safety and that humans will remotely monitor the fleet.
Remote access and control – known in the industry as 'teleoperation' – is used in varying degrees by the handful of robotaxi startups operating around the globe. The technology has clear advantages and important limitations.
Here are some details of how it works:
Teleoperation is the control of machines by humans in a different location, usually over a wireless network.
It is used to train robots to operate autonomously, monitor their autonomous activity, and take over when required.
The global robotaxi industry is still in test mode, as companies deploy the vehicles in limited geographic areas and continually adjust the artificial intelligence software that controls them. Teleoperation is often used to intervene when a vehicle is unsure of what to do.
Alphabet's Waymo, for example, has a team of human 'fleet response' agents who respond to questions from the Waymo Driver – its bot.
'Much like phone-a-friend, when the Waymo vehicle encounters a particular situation on the road, the autonomous driver can reach out to a human fleet response agent for additional information,' Waymo said in a blog post last year.
Former Waymo CEO John Krafcik told Reuters, 'the cars aren't being actively monitored,' adding that the software is 'the ultimate decision-maker.'
A Waymo video shows a car asking a remote operator whether a street with emergency response vehicles is open to traffic. When the human says yes, the vehicle proceeds.
In contrast, other companies, such as Baidu's Apollo Go in China, have used fully remote backup drivers who can step in to virtually drive the vehicles. Baidu declined to comment.
Driving vehicles remotely on public roads has a major potential problem: it relies on cellular data connections that can drop or operate with a lag, disconnecting the vehicle from the remote driver in dangerous situations.
Philip Koopman, a Carnegie Mellon University engineering professor and autonomous-vehicle safety expert, said that approach could work for a small test deployment of 10 vehicles, such as Tesla's initial effort in Austin, but he called teleoperation 'inherently unreliable technology.'
'Eventually you will lose connection at exactly the worst time,' he said. 'If they've done their homework, this won't ever happen for 10 cars. With a million cars, it's going to happen every day.'
Former Waymo CEO Krafcik agreed, adding that the time delay in cell signal makes remote driving 'very risky.'
On the other hand, relying on the vehicle to reach out for help and allowing the vehicle to be the decision-maker are risky as well, Koopman said, as it does not guarantee the vehicle will make the right decision.
Waymo declined to comment on the limitations of its approach.
Koopman also noted there are limits to how many vehicles one person can safely monitor.
A group of Democratic Texas lawmakers asked Tesla on Wednesday to delay its robotaxi launch until September, when a new autonomous-driving law is scheduled to take effect. The Austin-area lawmakers said in a letter that delaying the launch 'is in the best interest of both public safety and building public trust in Tesla's operations.'
Musk for years has promised, without delivering, that its Full Self-Driving (Supervised) advanced driver assistance software would graduate to completely self-driving and control robotaxis. This year, he said Tesla would roll out a paid service in Austin underpinned by an 'unsupervised' version of the software.
'Teslas will be in the wild, with no one in them, in June, in Austin,' Musk told analysts and investors in January. In May, he told CNBC that the robotaxi would only operate in parts of Austin that are safe for it, would avoid difficult intersections, and would use humans to monitor the vehicles.
What those teleoperators will do is not clear.
For years inside Tesla, company executives have expected to use teleoperators who could take over in case of trouble, said one person familiar with the matter. For instance, if a robotaxi were stuck in a crowded pedestrian area and confused about what to do next, a human teleoperator could take over and guide it, the source said.
Tesla advertised for teleoperation positions, saying the company needs the ability to 'access and control' autonomous vehicles and humanoid robots remotely. Such employees can 'remotely perform complex and intricate tasks,' it said in the advertisements.
Tesla did not respond to a request for comment.
'We are being super paranoid about safety, so the date could shift,' Musk said in a post on X last week while providing a tentative launch date of June 22.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
NDTV
2 hours ago
- NDTV
Tesla To Launch Paid Robotaxi Service In Austin With Driverless Model Y SUVs
San Francisco: Elon Musk's vision of Tesla's future is set for a public test on Sunday, when a dozen or so self-driving cars in Austin, Texas start a limited, paid robotaxi service. Though Tesla is dispensing with a webcast product launch event helmed by Musk, fans will be scouring the internet for videos and reports from the coterie of invited riders that will be allowed to hail the small stable of Model Y SUVs for trips within a limited area of the city, accompanied by a Tesla safety monitor in the front passenger seat. The driver's seat will be empty. "Wow. We are going to ride in driverless Teslas in just a few days. On public roads," posted Omar Qazi, an user with 635,200 followers who writes often about Tesla using the handle @WholeMarsBlog and received an invite. The service in Austin will have other restrictions as well. Tesla plans to avoid bad weather, difficult intersections, and won't take anyone below the age of 18. Musk has said he is ready to delay the start for safety reasons, if needed. Tesla is worth more than most of its biggest rivals combined, and Musk has said that is supported by the company's future ability to create robotaxis and humanoid robots. For years, he has promised self-driving cars were just around the corner. Commercializing autonomous vehicles has been risky and expensive. GM's Cruise was shut down after a fatal accident and regulators are closely watching Tesla and its rivals, Alphabet's Waymo, which runs a paid robotaxi service in several US cities, and Amazon's Zoox. Tesla is also bucking the young industry's standard practice of relying on multiple technologies to read the road, using only cameras. That, says Musk, will be safe and much less expensive than lidar and radar systems added by rivals. Nonetheless, Musk says he is being "super paranoid about safety" with the rollout. "So far, this launch lags significantly behind the company's promise and what competitors have already delivered," said technology researcher Forrester's principal analyst Paul Miller. Fans have welcomed the caution and the long-awaited arrival. Qazi said on X, Tesla was launching "extremely cautiously, which is good."
Mint
6 hours ago
- Mint
Tesla's robotaxis are here: Everything you need to know
Tesla is rolling out its long-awaited robotaxi service in Austin, Texas, on Sunday, opening the electric-vehicle maker to the growing autonomous ride-hailing market, where its technology will be put to the test against market leader Waymo. Chief Executive Elon Musk has said the company will start small with up to 20 Tesla Model Ys driving on public roads, before expanding the service based on the technology's performance. There won't be a human driver behind the wheel. In an invitation shared on social media, Tesla said there would be a safety monitor sitting in the front-right passenger seat. Here is what to know about Tesla's robotaxi service. A robotaxi is a driverless, autonomous vehicle that operates like a taxicab or ride-hailing service. Several companies are testing or operating robotaxi services in the U.S., including Alphabet's Waymo and Zoox. Tesla's new robotaxi service employs Model Y electric SUVs piloted by an advanced version of Tesla's driver-assistance software, which it calls Full Self-Driving, or FSD. The Model Y is equipped with eight cameras that act as sensors for FSD. That is the same setup as the Model Y vehicles currently available for purchase. The version available to Tesla owners requires the driver to pay attention to the road and be prepared to take over plans to introduce two specially designed robotaxis to its service: a small, gold-colored sedan called the Cybercab, and a larger multiseater called the Robovan. Those vehicles have neither steering wheels nor pedals and could hit the road as soon as 2026. Tesla opened up its robotaxi service to a limited number of customers in Austin, where the company has its headquarters. The service is available within a geofenced area of Austin, where the company has been testing its vehicles. Musk has said the company is being cautious in how it rolls out this new technology. Before the launch, he warned that Tesla could change its plans. 'We are being super paranoid about safety," he wrote on X. Like Waymo and Zoox, Tesla will remotely monitor the performance of the vehicles and help them to navigate through difficult situations. Tesla has said the vehicles will be equipped with microphones to support their response to sirens from emergency vehicles. Musk has tied Tesla's fate to the performance of its robotics and artificial intelligence business. He forecasts that autonomous vehicles could add $5 trillion to $10 trillion to Tesla's market capitalization, which is currently around $1 trillion. Tesla's core business of manufacturing vehicles is under pressure and sales are declining as a result of increased competition and an aging vehicle lineup. Tesla also has faced a backlash from some owners and car buyers owing to Musk's work with the Trump administration. Last year, Tesla posted $98 billion in revenue, three-quarters of which came from car sales. Cathie Wood's ARK Invest projected that autonomous ride-hailing could be a $951 billion business for Tesla by 2029, at which point the service could make up around 90% of Tesla's earnings. Former Tesla President Jon McNeill, who is on the board of General Motors, said there is room for several autonomous-vehicle companies but questioned whether the robotaxi business is as large as Tesla and its supporters have projected. 'It's hard to square how people are arriving at a $1 trillion opportunity," he said. Some longtime investors are skeptical. The investor Gary Black recently said his Future Fund sold its remaining Tesla shares, citing the disconnect between its high market cap and declining vehicle sales. He doesn't think the robotaxi product will do much to boost the company's value. 'I don't see the upside at this point, but I see plenty of downside," he said. Industry leader Waymo said it makes more than 250,000 paid trips a week in San Francisco, Los Angeles, Phoenix and Austin. That business currently operates at a loss, but the company has said it sees a path to profitability. Zoox is available for use by its employees and invited guests in Las Vegas and the San Francisco Bay Area. It plans to launch in Austin and Miami and is also testing in Los Angeles, Seattle and Atlanta. Other companies have permits to test autonomous-vehicle technology, but most aren't able to offer rides to the public. Tesla has indicated it plans to expand services quickly to San Francisco, Los Angeles and San Antonio. By the end of 2026, Musk said he expects there to be hundreds of thousands of Teslas driving fully autonomously on roads in the U.S. Musk expects that many of those will be personally owned vehicles running Tesla's most-advanced version FSD software. He has compared his plans to a combination of the vacation-rental company Airbnb and Uber Technologies. Tesla faces some regulatory hurdles. Currently, autonomous vehicles are regulated at the state level and, in some cases, by cities. Musk has called for federal regulations, which would make it easier for the company to deploy its software on Teslas across the country. Write to Becky Peterson at
Time of India
7 hours ago
- Time of India
Would you hail 'robotaxi'? Musk bets cabs will give Tesla lift after boycotts, sales plunge
Elon Musk promised in 2019 that driverless Tesla "robotaxis" would be on the road "next year," but it didn't happen. A year later, he promised to deliver them the next year, but that didn't happen either. Despite the empty pledges the promises kept coming. Last year in January, Musk said, "Next year for sure, we'll have over a million robotaxis." Would you settle for 10 or 12? Musk appears to be on the verge of making his robotaxi vision a reality with a test run of a small squad of self-driving cabs in Austin, Texas, starting Sunday. Reaching a million may take a year or more, however, although the billionaire should be able to expand the service this year if the Austin demo is a success. The stakes couldn't be higher, nor the challenges. While Musk was making those "next year" promises, rival Waymo was busy deploying driverless taxis in Los Angeles, San Diego, Austin and other cities by using a different technology that allowed it to get to market faster. It just completed its 10 millionth paid ride. Boycotts related to Musk's politics have tanked Tesla's sales. Rival electric vehicle makers with newly competitive models have stolen market share. And investors are on edge after a USD 150 billion stock wipeout when Musk picked a social media fight with a US president overseeing federal car regulators who could make the robotaxi rollout much more difficult. The stock has recovered somewhat after Musk said he regretted some of his remarks. Tesla shareholders have stood by Musk over the years because he's defied the odds by building a successful standalone electric vehicle company - self-driving car promises aside - and making them a lot of money in the process. A decade ago, Tesla shares traded for around USD 18. The shares closed Friday at USD 322. Musk says the Austin test will begin modestly enough, with just 10 or 12 vehicles picking up passengers in a limited area. But then it will quickly ramp up and spread to other cities, eventually reaching hundreds of thousands if not a million vehicles next year. Some Musk watchers on Wall Street are sceptical. "How quickly can he expand the fleet?" asks Garrett Nelson, an analyst at CFRA. "We're talking maybe a dozen vehicles initially. It's very small." Morningstar's Seth Goldstein says Musk is being classic Musk: Promising too much, too quickly. "When anyone in Austin can download the app and use a robotaxi, that will be a success, but I don't think that will happen until 2028," he says. "Testing is going to take a while." Musk's tendency to push up the stock high with a bit of hyperbole is well known among investors. In 2018, he told Tesla stockholders he had "funding secured" to buy all their shares at a massive premium and take the company private. But he not only lacked a written commitment from financiers, according to federal stock regulators who fined him, he hadn't discussed the loan amount or other details with them. More recently, Musk told CNBC in May that Tesla was experiencing a "major rebound" in demand. A week later an auto trade group in Europe announced sales had plunged by half. Musk has come under fire for allegedly exaggerating the ability of the system used for its cars to drive themselves, starting with the name. Full Self-Driving is a misnomer. The system still requires drivers to keep their eyes on the road because they may need to intervene and take control at any moment. Federal highway safety regulators opened an investigation into FSD last year after several accidents, and the Department of Justice has conducted its own probe, though the status of that is not known. Tesla has also faced lawsuits over the feature, some resulting in settlements, other dismissed. In one case, a judge ruled against the plaintiffs but only because they hadn't proved Musk "knowingly" made false statements. Musk says the robotaxis will be running on an improved version of Full Self-Driving and the cabs will be safe. He also says the service will be able to expand rapidly around the country. His secret weapon: Millions of Tesla owners now on the roads. He says an over-the-air software update will soon allow them to turn their cars into driverless cabs and start a side business while stuck at the office for eight hours or on vacation for a week. "Instead of having your car sit in the parking lot, your car could be earning money," Musk said earlier this year, calling it an Airbnb model for cars. "You will be able to add or subtract your car to the fleet." Musk says Tesla also can move fast to deploy taxis now because of his decision to rely only on cameras for the cars to navigate, unlike Waymo, which has gone a more expensive route by supplementing its cameras with lasers and radar. "Tesla will have, I don't know," Musk mused in an conference call with investors, "99 per cent market share or something ridiculous." Given Waymo's head start and potential competition from Amazon and others, dominating the driverless market to that extent could be a reach. But Dan Ives, a Wedbush Securities analyst and big Musk fan, says this time Musk may actually pull it off because of Tesla's ability to scale up quickly. And even sceptics like Morningstar's Goldstein acknowledge that Musk occasionally does gets things right, and spectacularly so. He upended the car industry by getting people to buy expensive electric vehicles , brought his Starlink satellite internet service to rural areas and, more recently, performed a gee-whiz trick of landing an unmanned SpaceX rocket on a platform back on earth. "Maybe his timelines aren't realistic," Goldstein says, "but he can develop futuristic technology products."
