Netanyahu is using Muslim women's 'rights' to justify his war. What hideous, hollow hypocrisy

The Israeli prime minister, Benjamin Netanyahu, has invoked the Iranian regime's heinous women's rights record to justify his heinous war on Iran. This is the man whose genocide of Palestinians in Gaza killed more women and children in its first year than the equivalent period of any other conflict over the past two decades.
'They've impoverished you, they've given you misery, they've given you death, they've given you terror, they shoot down your women, leaving this brave, unbelievable woman, Mahsa Amini, to bleed on the sidewalk for not covering her hair,' he told Iranians in an interview with Iran International.
It is incredible to hear Netanyahu call on the Iranian people to rise up against the very things he has subjected Palestinians to. But it is not surprising. I am all too familiar with the ways imperialists, occupiers and invaders weaponise Muslim women's bodies and rights to justify their wars.
As an Egyptian, I know that colonisers such as Evelyn Baring, the 1st Earl of Cromer and the de facto ruler of Egypt between 1883 and 1907, supported greater rights for Egyptian women while being an anti-suffragist back home. Far from emancipating Egyptian women, Baring made it almost impossible for those opposed to the occupation and European influence to criticise traditions or religious practices without looking as though they were taking the side of the west.
As a woman of Muslim descent, I remember vividly the US claiming its invasion of Afghanistan was to 'liberate' women from the Taliban's misogyny. Twenty years after that reckless invasion, an increasingly disastrous war and occupation, and a criminally chaotic withdrawal from Afghanistan, the Taliban once again rule.
Even worse and more shamefully, as a feminist I know that, unlike Afghan feminists, white feminists in the US were cheerleaders of that invasion, failing to understand the dangers of imperial powers co-opting women's rights. Leaders of the Feminist Majority Foundation – including Eleanor Smeal, the former head of the National Organization for Women – attended events at the state department and met administration officials. The spring 2002 issue of Ms magazine called the invasion a 'coalition of hope'.
'As we achieve our objective, we are also clearing the path for you to achieve your freedom,' said Netanyahu in another televised speech aimed at Iranians. 'This is your opportunity to stand up and let your voices be heard. Woman, life, freedom – zan, zendegi, azadi.'
The death of Mahsa Amini, a 22-year-old Kurdish woman, in a hospital in Iran in September 2022 days after being detained by the regime's 'morality police' for allegedly not complying with the country's hijab regulation, sparked the feminist 'woman, life, freedom' revolution. Women, queer people and marginalised minorities in Iran rose up to fight not only the regime's compulsory hijab law but its decades of repression.
They did not need Netanyahu to fight for their freedom then, nor do they need him now. On the contrary, his attempt to co-opt the courageous uprising is the quickest way to discredit feminism itself – often dismissed as 'western' and alien. Wars and invasions harm, not strengthen, revolutions. As an Egyptian, I know all too well that the Egyptian regime tried its hardest to claim our 25 January revolution in 2011 was being masterminded from abroad.
Protecting the 'liberal' and 'western' values of women's rights is an easy moral cover for what is an invasion, war or colonisation always motivated by a desire for power, resources or both. If western leaders really cared so much about female bodily autonomy, perhaps they could look closer to home. The same George W Bush who claimed to defend women from the burqa and the Taliban was the same George W Bush who, on his first day in office, cut off funding to any international family-planning organisations that offered abortion services or counselling.
Would the white feminists call for the invasion of the US today, where a premature baby was extracted from the decaying body of a brain-dead Black woman who, against the wishes of her partner and family, was treated like an incubator because of the state of Georgia's ban on abortion? The patriarchy-atop-theocracy melange of Iran's 'morality police' is easier to see because it is so visibly expressed in the enforced hijab. But what is the enforced pregnancy of the Christian zealots in the US but a melange of patriarchy built atop theocracy right there?
Wars and invasions do not liberate women. Ask the women of Afghanistan today. Every time an imperial power claims to 'liberate' women from 'their' men, those men will seek to wrestle back control over 'their women' when the invaders are gone. Taliban 2.0 have banned girls' education and barred women from working in public and private sectors, except for Afghan healthcare and a few other departments. They have barred women from travelling long distances by road or air unless accompanied by a male relative, and from visiting public places such as parks, gyms and bathhouses without a male relative. The Taliban have shut down even women-only beauty salons.
As a feminist, I marvelled at and cheered on fellow feminists in Iran rising up for woman, life, freedom. And I am sure they know that the enemy of their enemy is not their friend.
Mona Eltahawy writes the Feminist Giant newsletter. She is the author of The Seven Necessary Sins for Women and Girls and Headscarves and Hymens: Why the Middle East Needs a Sexual Revolution
Do you have an opinion on the issues raised in this article? If you would like to submit a response of up to 300 words by email to be considered for publication in our letters section, please click here.

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

Sky News

31 minutes ago

• Sky News

Israel-Iran live: Iran and Israel exchange attacks - a day after Tehran rules out nuclear negotiations

Iran and Israel have been exchanging attacks after Tehran ruled out nuclear negotiations with US while it is facing "Israeli aggression". Reports have suggested a nuclear facility site in Iran has been "targeted". Listen to our Trump 100 podcast as you scroll.

Times

an hour ago

• Times

Eight arrests as protesters ‘attacked' outside Iranian embassy in London

Eight men have been arrested after anti-regime activists were allegedly assaulted outside the Iranian embassy on Friday morning. Scores of police officers were deployed to the scene after being alerted to reports of an altercation outside the building in Knightsbridge, west London, just before 10am. Two men were treated at the scene by paramedics before being taken to hospital. Officials said their injuries are not believed to be life-threatening. • Iran's 'propagandist-in-chief' billed to speak at Scottish mosque Police imposed conditions stopping protesters from gathering in the area until 1pm on Sunday to 'prevent serious disorder', but one man was arrested for allegedly breaching the civil order. Scotland Yard said seven men were arrested on suspicion of grievous bodily harm. All suspects remained in police custody on Friday afternoon. Amir, 30, a member of a pro-Iranian monarchy group, claimed one of the two injured men suffered a 'broken leg'. The construction worker, who withheld his surname, said the activists had staged a 'peaceful protest' outside the embassy since the Israeli attacks on Iran began last week. Amir claimed the members have had 'problems' with supporters of the Islamic regime during that time. The protest was said to have been an anti-regime demonstration, amid the continuing Israel-Iran conflict. The police said the rally involved both pro and anti-regime protesters. Pro-Shah protesters were seen flying different flags supporting Crown Prince Reza Pahlavi, including the national flag used before the 1979 Islamist revolution. Officers were seen on patrol in the area to monitor the situation after cordons were lifted later in the afternoon. Pro-Iranian monarchy protesters told The Times they were told to disperse and dismantle flags and banners festooned on railings opposite the embassy. The Metropolitan Police said: 'Officers are on scene in Princes Gate, SW7, following an altercation during a protest. 'They were called at 9.53am on Friday. Conditions have since been put in place to prevent serious disorder.' The police said that eight men remained in police custody and that the two men treated at the scene were in hospital. London Ambulance Service added: 'We were called at 9.56am on [Friday] to reports of an assault in Princes Gate. 'We sent a number of resources to the scene including ambulance crews, paramedics in fast response cars and our tactical response unit. We treated two patients at the scene and took one to hospital and one to a major trauma centre.' The attack unfolded as the war between Israel and Iran continued to escalate and both nations engaged in missile strikes. President Trump said that he would decide in the next fortnight whether or not the US would intervene in the conflict.

The Independent

an hour ago

• The Independent

Israel-Iran latest: Israel strikes Iran's largest nuclear research facility after huge explosion rocks Haifa

Iran and Israel launched a new round of strikes early Saturday, a day after Tehran ruled out nuclear talks while under threat and European powers continued efforts to revive diplomacy. The Israeli military said it had carried out a wave of attacks on missile storage and launch sites across Iran. Israeli defence minister Israel Katz confirmed that among those killed was Saeed Izadi, a senior commander in the Quds Force, the overseas wing of the Islamic Revolutionary Guards Corps (IRGC). Iran's Fars news agency reported that Israel had targeted the Isfahan nuclear facility, one of the country's largest, but said there was no leakage of hazardous material. Iranian media also reported an Israeli strike on a building in the city of Qom, where a 16-year-old was reportedly killed and two others injured. Meanwhile, US president Donald Trump slammed the US intelligence Community's assessment of Iran's nuclear weapons program and claimed Tehran could produce a working weapon within a 'matter of weeks'. At the United Nations Security Council on Friday, Israel's envoy Danny Danon declared the country would continue its military operations 'until Iran's nuclear threat is dismantled.' Watch: Russia's defence of Iran shows need to tighten sanctions, says Zelensky 21 June 2025 07:20 Experts say Israel's current strikes on Iran's nuclear installations so far pose only limited risks of contamination, but warn any attack on the country's nuclear power station at Bushehr could cause a nuclear disaster. Fears of a nuclear catastrophe rippled through the Gulf on Thursday after the Israeli military mistakenly announced a strike in Bushehr, home to Iran's only nuclear power station, only to say later that the announcement was a mistake. Do Israeli attacks on Iran risk nuclear contamination? Israel has said it is determined to destroy Iran's nuclear capabilities, while avoiding any nuclear disaster in the region Shahana Yasmin21 June 2025 07:10 UN nuclear watchdog urges restraint as Israel strikes nuclear-linked sites in Iran The head of the UN's nuclear watchdog has warned against any military action targeting Iran's nuclear reactors. At an emergency UN Security Council meeting, IAEA chief Rafael Grossi said: 'I want to make it absolutely and completely clear: In case of an attack on the Bushehr nuclear power plant, a direct hit would result in a very high release of radioactivity to the environment. This is the nuclear site in Iran where the consequences could be most serious.' So far, Israel has avoided targeting nuclear reactors, focusing instead on Iran's Natanz enrichment site, centrifuge workshops near Tehran, and the Arak heavy water facility. While initial reports indicated no damage at Arak, the IAEA later confirmed 'key buildings at the facility were damaged,' though no radioactive material was present. Shahana Yasmin21 June 2025 07:00 Israel says it killed Quds Force commander leading Palestine Corps Israeli defence minister Israel Katz said on Saturday that the military had killed Saeed Izadi, a senior commander in Iran's Quds Force, during a strike on an apartment in the city of Qom, according to Reuters. Izadi, who led the Palestine Corps within the Quds Force, the overseas arm of the Islamic Revolutionary Guards Corps (IRGC), was described as a veteran figure in Iran's regional operations. Shahana Yasmin21 June 2025 06:47 Who's who in the secret group advising Trump on Iran - who has been left out of the planning? President Donald Trump let it be known on Thursday that he will make a decision on whether to involve the U.S. in Israel's war with Iran within the next two weeks, as tensions over the question continue to divide conservatives. The president, who signed off on attack plans on Tuesday but resisted giving the go-ahead, is reportedly taking soundings from a small coterie of trusted advisers while also throwing the conversation open to fellow world leaders, as well as allies such as the hawkish Republican senators Lindsey Graham of South Carolina and Tom Cotton of Arkansas. Keep reading: Who's who in the secret group advising Trump on Iran President Donald Trump is huddling with small circle of trusted advisers about whether to join Israeli military offensive Joe Sommerlad21 June 2025 06:30 Israel vows to continue strikes until Iran's nuclear programme is dismantled Israel pledged on Friday to keep up its military offensive against Iran until Tehran's nuclear capabilities are fully dismantled, Reuters reported. 'Though our homes, our families and our children are under threat, we will not stop,' Israeli UN Ambassador Danny Danon told the United Nations Security Council. 'Not until Iran's nuclear threat is dismantled. Not until its war machine is disarmed. Not until our people and yours are safe.' In response, Iran's ambassador to the UN, Amir Saeid Iravani, called on the Security Council to intervene to halt Israel's attacks. 'Israel apparently declared that it will continue this strike for as many days as it takes,' he said. 'We are alarmed by credible reports that the United States... may be joining this war.' Shahana Yasmin21 June 2025 06:20 Iran faces near-total internet blackout amid conflict with Israel As the war between Iran and Israel enters its second week, much of Iran remains in a near-total communication blackout, leaving millions unable to connect with the outside world or even with friends and family across the country. According to internet monitoring group NetBlocks, Iran has been largely cut off from global internet access for more than 60 hours. 'The internet shutdown continues to severely limit the public's ability to express political viewpoints, communicate freely, and follow safety alerts amid ongoing conflict with Israel,' it said on X, formerly Twitter. Shahana Yasmin21 June 2025 06:10 Do Israeli attacks on Iran risk nuclear contamination? Do Israeli attacks on Iran risk nuclear contamination? Israel has said it is determined to destroy Iran's nuclear capabilities, while avoiding any nuclear disaster in the region Reuters21 June 2025 06:00 Ex-CIA chief warns US would trigger regional war by striking Iran Former CIA director and defence secretary Leon Panetta has warned that any US military strike on Iran would almost certainly plunge the country into a wider regional war. Panetta said the US made a 'terrible mistake' by invading Iraq two decades ago and urged US president Trump to heed the lessons of the past. 'It's a lesson that the president needs to learn, because if he goes in and attacks Iran, then there's no question that the United States would be in a regional war at that point,' Panetta told CNN, adding that Iran would inevitably retaliate. 'So make no mistake about it. It may be an airstrike, but it would definitely involve the United States in a war.' Shahana Yasmin21 June 2025 05:50 Iran signals openness to diplomacy, but only if Israel halts attacks Iran has said it is open to pursuing diplomatic talks with European nations, but only on the condition that Israel ends its military operations and those responsible are held to account. Following a meeting in Geneva with European diplomats, foreign minister Abbas Araghchi expressed 'serious concern' over the failure of France, Germany, the UK, and the EU to condemn what he described as Israel's surprise strike and ongoing aggression against Iran. He warned that any assault on Iran's peaceful nuclear facilities would represent a severe violation of international law. 'I explicitly and clearly stated that Iran's defensive capabilities are not negotiable,' the minister said, reported the Associated Press. However, he added that Iran is ready to keep talking with the Europeans 'in the near future'. His comments came as Israel's top military commander said the country was preparing for a potentially prolonged conflict.