New childcare fee cap will not benefit most parents
A new fee cap for early learning and childcare will not have a significant impact for the majority of parents, new figures show.
Minister for children Norma Foley announced a maximum fee cap for new and existing services taking part in core funding. Under this, the highest possible fees will be no more than €295 per week for a full day care place that would come in at 40-50 hours a week.
However, according to figures from the Department of Children, the highest average fees being paid at the moment is in the Dún Laoghaire-Rathdown area of Dublin at €258.
The department said the fee cap will bring fees 'closer to the average weekly fee of €197 for full day care'.
The figures, released to Social Democrats TD Aidan Farrelly, show that Cork, Dublin, Kildare, Meath, and Wicklow are the only counties with a current average above €197.
Mr Farrelly said that while he welcomes the announcement, the move falls short of addressing the significant issues facing families who are trying to find a place for their child or workers who do not have pay parity with their peers.
The department of education said the cap will bring fees closer to the average weekly fee of €197 for full day care — but Cork, Dublin, Kildare, Meath, and Wicklow are the only counties with a current average weekly fee above €197. iStock
'In recent months, I have met with stakeholders in the early years education and childcare sector such as staff and unions, service providers, and families — who all maintain that the systemic issues facing the sector such as recruitment and retention, access and affordability will not be addressed with increases to funding in the current model,' he said.
'I have consistently asked the minister and this Government to consider establishing a cross-party special Oireachtas committee on the future of childcare and early years education to take a similar approach to Sláintecare which would map out a vision for the future of the sector having heard directly from all stakeholders.'
While announcing the fee cap, as well as an increase in investment of €60m, Ms Foley said it would reduce the cost for families who are facing the highest fees across the country in around 10% of early learning and childcare providers.
'It will address some of the extreme fee disparities across the sector in a meaningful way, so that there are more consistent rates in place for families in their local area,' said Ms Foley.
During the general election, there was a great deal of talk from the coalition parties, and others, about a maximum payment of €200 per child per month for early learning and childcare, a promise which Ms Foley said would be kept.
'I have been very clear that we will do that over the lifetime of this Government so it will be incremental.
"Like the steps we take today, we are starting at the very top where there is an extraordinary high cost to parents and we are beginning to bring that down as we have seen over the last number of years,' said Ms Foley.
The core funding scheme is now in its fourth year and despite a warning last year that there would be a mass exodus of providers, Ms Foley said there has actually been a net increase of 226 providers.
Among the issues raised by frustrated providers was struggling to retain staff in a competitive labour market but it is hoped that the €45m ringfenced for the increased minimum pay rates for the sector will help to remedy this issue.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Independent
an hour ago
- Irish Independent
Eoin O'Malley: CityWest deal shows the State is in the asylum business for the long haul, but the opposite approach is working for Denmark
The Danes are pursuing a 'zero refugee' policy and is sending out a strong message about how tough its rules are Today at 21:30 If we were to choose a monument to Irish policy failure, we could do worse than to pick the Citywest Hotel. The Government last week authorised the purchase of the hotel in Saggart, Co Dublin, to become a state-owned International Protection Accommodation Service (IPAS) centre for asylum-seekers. Citywest was built by businessman Jim Mansfield, who borrowed heavily to expand it to become one of the largest hotels in Europe. It became host to some large events. All-Ireland champions partied there after victory. It was where the Fianna Fáil faithful gathered when the party was in its heyday. The faux-Georgian hotel seemed to symbolise Celtic Tiger excess and hubris.
Irish Independent
an hour ago
- Irish Independent
The Sunday Independent's View: Time is running out for the Government to get a grip on housing
For the Government, it offers an opportunity for reflection as it nears the halfway stage of its own first year. What has been achieved since coming into office again in January? The administration has been accused of seeming less like a new broom than a threadbare old brush; not so much sweeping clean as brushing the country's problems under a rug to be tidied up later. But defenders of the Fianna Fáil/Fine Gael-led Coalition would no doubt argue it has been faced with a series of obstacles since the start of the year, most notably the still unresolved threat of tariffs from Donald Trump. There is also the worsening international situation, which last week saw Ireland join other countries in pulling embassy staff from Iran as the conflict with Israel continues. These, however, are matters with which all our partners are having to deal. It is no excuse for not dealing robustly with domestic matters. The legislation programme for the summer term of the Oireachtas lists a number of bills as a priority, including the Defence (Amendment) Bill which will remove the so-called triple-lock on Irish troops serving abroad, as well as measures tackling air pollution, cyber security and terrorism. All important matters, no question about it. The logjam in planning and services is well documented But none directly addresses the deepest issue confronting the country: that is, of course, the lack of supply, and crippling cost, of housing. Last week there was more bad news as the Central Bank revised downward its forecast for the number of houses that will be built between now and 2027 — also the midway point of the 34th Dáil, a date which the Government may find itself careening towards at an alarming pace. This year, it now expects 32,500 homes to be built, well short of what is needed to make a significant dent in the target of 300,000 by 2030. The logjam in planning and services is well documented. Historically, it has often felt as if Irish bureaucracy stymies rather than stimulates innovation. No wonder we lag far behind comparable EU states when it comes to infrastructure. The apparent lack of urgency to break through these roadblocks remains a bigger concern. The Government already seems to have retreated into explaining rather than doing, as if seeking to justify in advance the failure to meet its own target, which it has already accepted is inevitable. The appointment of the former HSE chief executive as chair of the newly revamped An Coimisiún Pleanála may make a difference. If anyone has experience of cutting through red tape, it is Paul Reid. Health is another area where much-needed change sadly comes a cropper. Ministers must act swiftly to hand him the power to green-light the infrastructure projects needed to house an estimated population of six million by 2040. No other achievements by this Government will be worth a penny candle if the crisis in housing does not ease dramatically. The summer recess is set to begin less than a month from now, on July 18. When TDs and senators return in September, all eyes will be on the presidential election and it will be the winter solstice before we know it. It is still not too late to get a grip on housing, but it soon might be if more time is wasted.
Irish Independent
an hour ago
- Irish Independent
AIB likely to quadruple chief executive Colin Hunt's pay package to €2m after government exit
The sale of the State's final 2.06pc stake has freed the bank from the Government-imposed salary cap on banker pay. It is likely that AIB will look to bump up Hunt's pay – and also add in a equivalent share allowance to at least match that of Bank of Ireland CEO Myles O'Grady. O'Grady is paid a basic rate of €950,000 before his pension or bonus at Bank of Ireland, which divested from State ownership in 2022. That compares to the €500,000 basic wage that his AIB counterpart receives. After pension and bonuses are included, Hunt is currently paid just over €600,000 a year. 'To be fair, a salary of €500,000 for the CEO of the largest bank in Ireland is not competitive. It's well below market rate,' said banking analyst John Cronin of SeaPoint Insights. 'Bank of Ireland pays Myles O'Grady €950k and it pays CFO Mark Spain €600k. So I would say that the CEO and CFO of AIB will go to those levels at least pretty quickly. It's hard for the general public to get their heads around pay packages above €500k "They'll probably keep CEO pay just below €1m. It'd be a surprise if they didn't match Bank of Ireland, and they might go around €25,000 more,' he said. Now that the Government has sold its stake and the salary cap at the bank has been removed, industry sources believe AIB is also likely to add a lucrative fixed share allowance to Hunt's package – effectively matching O'Grady's deal. Bank of Ireland's top executives currently get a fixed share allowance of 50pc of salary, introduced after the State sold its final shares in the bank in 2022. That fixed share allowance is expected to rise to 100pc next year. 'It's hard for the general public to get their heads around pay packages above five hundred grand and why a CEO has to be paid a million,' admitted another industry source, adding that Hunt was seen as unlikely to seek work with banks in London or elsewhere. 'I'd think he would probably attach a huge amount of value to living here, from a family point of view. He's also in the middle of every significant macroeconomic debate in Ireland because of his position – and I wouldn't underestimate the value he attaches to that. 'But if you want to hang on to that management team and keep them together, then you have to compete in the marketplace. And now they have the freedom to compete. "It would be kind of dysfunctional to have a banking market where one big bank can pay double what the other big bank pays, when they're more or less doing the exact same thing,' said the source. Cronin feels the pay cap should never have been introduced. 'I get that it worked politically. But you have to pay people properly to do a job. They could move to another smaller bank and get paid twice the amount and more. The danger is you get runaway cost-inflation across the sector "There is no doubt shareholders saw an ongoing retention risk in relation to the management team and they were not happy about that.' Cronin said bankers are disappointed that Finance Minister Paschal Donohoe did not remove the ban on variable performance-related bonuses above €20,000. 'My own view is that he should, but I can totally understand why he didn't. The danger is you get runaway cost-inflation across the sector. 'But the problem is that it creates cynicism within the sector, where people say that it's OK for the top guys to get paid properly, but not everyone else. And it can drive fixed-pay inflation, which is less ideal from a cost flexibility standpoint.'
