Row over rebate on capital gains tax settled in taxpayers' favour
Ahmedabad: The rebate row over capital gains tax has taken a decisive turn. With the Centre amending
Section 87A
through the Finance Act, 2025, the law now clearly denies rebates on income taxed under special rates, including capital gains.
Tired of too many ads? go ad free now
But here's the twist — the change is forward-looking, not retrospective. That gives taxpayers a strong legal footing to claim missed rebates from previous years.
The debate over the eligibility of rebate under Section 87A of the Income-Tax Act — particularly concerning tax on
short-term capital gains
(STCG) from equity shares under Section 111A and
long-term capital gains
(LTCG) from listed securities under Section 112 — has been a long-standing one.
The Central Board of Direct Taxes (CBDT), in its Budget 2025 FAQs, clarified that rebates under Section 87A are only available for taxes calculated as per slab rates under the new tax regime (Section 115BAC) and not on capital gains, lotteries, or other special-rate incomes.
International tax expert Mukesh Patel explained that the legislative amendment now restricts the rebate to only the tax payable under Section 115BAC(1A).
"This amendment, applicable from Assessment Year 2026–27, shuts the door on future claims based on capital gains. But since it has been made prospectively, taxpayers can still claim such rebates for AYs 2024–25 and 2025–26," he said.
This update could offer significant relief to many taxpayers who faced rejection of their rebate claims after the CBDT, on July 5, 2024, instructed the Centralised Processing Centre (CPC) to block such claims in the ITR utility.
Tired of too many ads? go ad free now
The govt had earlier enhanced the scope of rebate — increasing the income threshold from Rs 5 lakh to Rs 7 lakh and the rebate amount from Rs 12,500 to Rs 25,000 — to push taxpayers toward the new regime under Section 115BAC. However, the tax department refused to extend these benefits to capital gains incomes, which sparked protests and legal challenges.
"The Bombay high court directed the reopening of the ITR utility.
However, the department continued to reject claims for rebate in this regard, without heeding the view that taxpayers could not be deprived of their legitimate claim, as there was no amendment in law to support its interpretation," said Patel.
Mukesh Patel said, "After above-referred amendment, introduced only with prospective effect, there is no room for controversy any longer. Taxpayers can easily defend their claims under appeal or even press for relief by way of revision or rectification in respect of concluded matters for Assessment Year 2024-25."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Economic Times
an hour ago
- Economic Times
FD rate up to 8.8% for senior citizens investing for three years; Know the list of banks
ET Online Tenant eviction: After more than 10 years fight a landlord wins eviction case on ground of rebuilding of property; Know how There are still some banks who continue to offer up to 8.8% interest rate on fixed deposits (FD) made by senior citizens (age 60 years and above) for three year tenure and not exceeding Rs 3 crore. Read below to know the list of banks offering FD interest rate up to 8.8%. Bank FD interest rate for senior citizens FD rate up to 8.8% Suryoday Small Finance Bank is offering 8.8% interest rate on FD of three year tenure. FD rate up to 8.75% for senior citizens Utkarsh Small Finance Bank is offering 8.75% interest rate on FD for three year tenure for senior citizens. Bank Name FD rate Suryoday Small Finance Bank 8.8% Utkarsh Small Finance Bank 8.75% Unity Small Finance Bank 8.5% slice Small Finance Bank 8.25% Jana Small Finance Bank 8.25% Source: as of June 18, 2025 FD rate up to 8.5% Unity Small Finance Bank is offering up to 8.5% interest rate on FD for three year tenure. FD rate up to 8.25% slice Small Finance Bank is offering 8.25% interest rate on FD for three year tenure. Similarly, Jana Small Finance Bank is offering 8.25% interest rate on FD for three year tenure. Disclaimer: While deposits in small finance banks are insured by the Deposit Insurance Credit Guarantee Corporation (DICGC) up to Rs 5 lakh, experts advise investors to exercise caution when investing in their FDs. Given their unique business model, the risk associated with investing in small finance bank FDs might differ slightly from that of scheduled commercial banks. To mitigate potential risks, it's recommended that investors limit their exposure to small finance bank FDs to an amount that falls within the DICGC coverage. This ensures that their principal and interest are protected in unforeseen circumstances. When is TDS deducted from bank FDs? TDS is required to be deducted by banks if the interest amount in an FD is above Rs 1 lakh in a particular bank. Do note that TDS is not any additional tax, you can get this tax back as a refund or adjust it with your total tax liability at the time of income tax return filing (ITR). Moreover, if you are eligible for a tax refund then you might be eligible for interest on tax instance, if a senior citizen's income is Rs 11 lakh then, it's not subject to income tax due to Section 87A tax rebate under the new tax regime for FY 2025-26. Section 87A tax rebate is available for up to Rs 12 lakh income level under the new tax a senior citizen can submit Form 15H to prevent TDS deduction if his total income after all deductions claim and Section 87A rebate is below the taxable limit like Rs 12 lakh for the new tax regime or Rs 5 lakh for the old tax the fact that no income tax is levied on such an income level (below Rs 12 lakh), banks and other financial institutions will still deduct TDS. This is because the law mandated them to deduct TDS once the interest/income amount crossed a particular threshold which was Rs 1 lakh for senior citizens. This happens because banks are not aware about tax liability and deduct TDS whenever the annual interest amount crosses Rs 1 lakh. So, can such a senior citizen file form 15H to avoid TDS on fixed deposits in such situations. N.R. Narayana Murthy Founder, Infosys Watch Now Harsh Mariwala Chairman & Founder, Marico Watch Now Adar Poonawalla CEO, Serum Institute of India Watch Now Ronnie Screwvala Chairperson & Co-founder, upGrad Watch Now Puneet Dalmia Managing Director, Dalmia Bharat group Watch Now Martin Schwenk Former President & CEO, Mercedes-Benz, Thailand Watch Now Nadir Godrej Managing Director, of Godrej Industries Watch Now Manu Jain Former- Global Vice President, Xiaomi Watch Now Nithin Kamath Founder, CEO, Zerodha Watch Now Anil Agarwal Executive Chairman, Vedanta Resources Watch Now Dr. Prathap C. Reddy Founder Chairman, Apollo Hospitals Watch Now Vikram Kirloskar Former Vice Chairman, Toyota Kirloskar Motor Watch Now Kiran Mazumdar Shaw Executive Chairperson, Biocon Limited Watch Now Shashi Kiran Shetty Chairman of Allcargo Logistics, ECU Worldwide and Gati Ltd Watch Now Samir K Modi Managing Director, Modi Enterprises Watch Now R Gopalakrishnan Former Director Tata Sons, Former Vice Chairman, HUL Watch Now Sanjiv Mehta Former Chairman / CEO, Hindustan Unilever Watch Now Dr Ajai Chowdhry Co-Founder, HCL, Chairman EPIC Foundation, Author, Just Aspire Watch Now Shiv Khera Author, Business Consultant, Motivational Speaker Watch Now Nakul Anand Executive Director, ITC Limited Watch Now RS Sodhi Former MD, Amul & President, Indian Dairy Association Watch Now Anil Rai Gupta Managing Director & Chairman, Havells Watch Now Zia Mody Co-Founder & Managing Partner, AZB & Partners Watch Now Arundhati Bhattacharya Chairperson & CEO, Salesforce India Watch Now
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
FD rate up to 8.8% for senior citizens investing for three years; Know the list of banks
Bank FD interest rate for senior citizens FD rate up to 8.8% FD rate up to 8.75% for senior citizens Academy Empower your mind, elevate your skills Bank Name FD rate Suryoday Small Finance Bank 8.8% Utkarsh Small Finance Bank 8.75% Unity Small Finance Bank 8.5% slice Small Finance Bank 8.25% Jana Small Finance Bank 8.25% FD rate up to 8.5% FD rate up to 8.25% When is TDS deducted from bank FDs? There are still some banks who continue to offer up to 8.8% interest rate on fixed deposits (FD) made by senior citizens (age 60 years and above) for three year tenure and not exceeding Rs 3 below to know the list of banks offering FD interest rate up to 8.8%. Suryoday Small Finance Bank is offering 8.8% interest rate on FD of three year tenure. Utkarsh Small Finance Bank is offering 8.75% interest rate on FD for three year tenure for senior as of June 18, 2025Unity Small Finance Bank is offering up to 8.5% interest rate on FD for three year Small Finance Bank is offering 8.25% interest rate on FD for three year Jana Small Finance Bank is offering 8.25% interest rate on FD for three year While deposits in small finance banks are insured by the Deposit Insurance Credit Guarantee Corporation (DICGC) up to Rs 5 lakh, experts advise investors to exercise caution when investing in their FDs. Given their unique business model, the risk associated with investing in small finance bank FDs might differ slightly from that of scheduled commercial banks. To mitigate potential risks, it's recommended that investors limit their exposure to small finance bank FDs to an amount that falls within the DICGC coverage. This ensures that their principal and interest are protected in unforeseen is required to be deducted by banks if the interest amount in an FD is above Rs 1 lakh in a particular bank. Do note that TDS is not any additional tax, you can get this tax back as a refund or adjust it with your total tax liability at the time of income tax return filing (ITR). Moreover, if you are eligible for a tax refund then you might be eligible for interest on tax instance, if a senior citizen's income is Rs 11 lakh then, it's not subject to income tax due to Section 87A tax rebate under the new tax regime for FY 2025-26. Section 87A tax rebate is available for up to Rs 12 lakh income level under the new tax a senior citizen can submit Form 15H to prevent TDS deduction if his total income after all deductions claim and Section 87A rebate is below the taxable limit like Rs 12 lakh for the new tax regime or Rs 5 lakh for the old tax the fact that no income tax is levied on such an income level (below Rs 12 lakh), banks and other financial institutions will still deduct TDS. This is because the law mandated them to deduct TDS once the interest/income amount crossed a particular threshold which was Rs 1 lakh for senior citizens. This happens because banks are not aware about tax liability and deduct TDS whenever the annual interest amount crosses Rs 1 lakh. So, can such a senior citizen file form 15H to avoid TDS on fixed deposits in such situations.
Mint
2 hours ago
- Mint
Jump in refunds depresses Centre's net direct tax revenue
New Delhi: A sharp jump in tax refunds has led to a modest dip in the union government's net tax revenue receipts from corporate and personal income to ₹4.59 trillion so far this year, official data showed. The union government's net direct tax revenue up to 19 June this year contracted 1.4% annually, although, before adjusting for refunds, it recorded 4.9% growth to ₹5.45 trillion, the Central Board of Direct Taxes (CBDT) said on Saturday. The Income Tax Department issued ₹86,385 crore of corporate and personal income tax refunds in the period, a 58% jump from the year-ago period. The bulk of it was in the corporate tax component. After refunds, non-corporate tax receipt, which mainly comprises personal income tax revenue, stood at ₹2.73 trillion, a slight improvement over the collections in the same period a year ago. Net corporate tax revenue of ₹1.73 trillion, on the other hand, clocked a 5% dip from the year-ago period. Before adjusting for refunds, corporate tax collections saw 9.5% growth and non-corporate taxes a near 1 % improvement, CBDT data showed. Sluggish growth in personal income tax Personal income tax collection growth remained sluggish after the government offered tax relief to middle-income earners in the FY26 budget presented on 1 February, which was estimated in the budget to result in revenue erosion of about ₹1 trillion a year. The tax relief was offered as a consumption stimulus for the economy which, over time, could result in improved demand for goods and services, income growth and better tax revenue collection. 'Refunds have increased by 58.04% as on 19 June compared to corresponding period of last year reflecting better taxpayer services and quicker issuance of refunds,' CBDT said. In terms of modes of payment, advance tax collection of corporate and non-corporate taxes so far this year stood at ₹1.5 trillion, an improvement of 3.87% from the year-ago period. 'Decent growth momentum' This rise in advance tax collection establishes that companies have experienced decent growth momentum in terms of reportable profits in the first quarter, said Amit Maheshwari, Tax Partner at AKM Global, a tax and consulting firm. 'However, the marginal dip in overall net collections can be attributed to higher tax refunds issued in first quarter of FY26. Overall, the numbers suggest that while the economy is stable, the pace of collections could vary depending on how key sectors perform in the face of global turmoil and how refunds are processed,' said Maheshwari.
