SPDC flags concerns as tobacco sector seeks tax relief in budget
LAHORE: The tobacco industry has called on the government to introduce a third tax tier and lower Federal Excise Duty (FED) in the upcoming budget, raising alarms among economists and public health experts about the potential impact on tax compliance and health policy.
As budget consultations continue, the industry has proposed a reduced FED of PKR 3,800 per 1,000 cigarette sticks—down from the current PKR 5,050—and the creation of a new tier with a lower rate of PKR 2,525 per 1,000 sticks. The demands have surfaced amid criticism of the sector's tax practices.
During a roundtable discussion hosted by the Sustainable Development Policy Institute (SDPI), Asif Iqbal of the Social Policy and Development Centre (SPDC) alleged that leading tobacco firms have manipulated production data to influence taxation policy. Iqbal noted that although cigarette production increased by 19.2% during 2023–24, revenue from FED saw a decline of 2.4%, while GST collection dropped 26.1%, pointing to a worrying mismatch between declared production and tax receipts.
He further stated that while nine tobacco companies are enrolled in the government's track and trace system, only three—accounting for 60% of the market—have implemented it using automated processes. This loophole, he said, allows underreporting and weakens tax monitoring efforts.
Experts have warned that acquiescing to these proposals could let the tobacco sector gain additional revenues of PKR 10–20 billion, at the cost of a significantly higher health burden for the country, potentially ten times greater than the revenue benefit.
Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Recorder
an hour ago
- Business Recorder
20% of the global oil supply passes through the Strait of Hormuz
Last week, the market was anticipating the Federal Open Market Committee's (FOMC's) decision on interest rates, with expectations for no changes, and indeed, the rates remained stable. However, the Fed did not offer any new insights to the markets. In contrast, Brazil's Central Bank raised its interest rate, while Norway's Central Bank surprised market participants with a reduction in its benchmark rate. Both the Swiss National Bank and Sweden's Central Bank also announced rate cuts. On the other hand, Pakistan's Central Bank, the State Bank of Pakistan (SBP), the Bank of Japan (BoJ), the Bank of England (BoE), and the Chilean Central Bank kept their rates steady. In his press conference, Fed Chairman Powell indicated that the outlook for monetary policy is quite uncertain. Although the Federal Reserve maintained its interest rate, market indicators are suggesting a potential up to 50 basis-point cut in September and in December. Discussions are already circulating about the possibility of a US rate cut as early as next month in July. Fed member Waller has said the Federal Reserve should not delay rate cuts for too long. Additionally, recent US data indicates that the 10% tariff levied on foreign goods has had minimal effect on consumer behaviour. Though spending has slowed, but it is clear that the ongoing trade war is negatively impacting business confidence and overall economic activity. The potential consequences of the Iran-Israel situation should also be taken into account. Oil prices have already risen, and any further escalation in tensions in the Middle East could lead to even higher prices. Analysts are particularly attentive to the increase in oil prices, as Europe relies heavily on foreign gas, with Iran being the third-largest supplier. Gas prices have also climbed alongside oil prices and should not be overlooked. Since the onset of the Iran-Israel conflict, oil prices have increased by nearly 10% per barrel. This past weekend, the market remained cautious and anxious amid deteriorating geopolitical conditions, avoiding risk-taking. This hesitancy was fueled by Donald Trump's statement that the US would take approximately two weeks to decide on potential involvement. However, this also implies that by the time this analysis is published, the US could take action against Iran. Only time will reveal the actual outcome. One thing is certain: if the US intervenes, oil prices could approach $ 100 as roughly 20% of the global oil supply passes through the Strait of Hormuz. Additionally, gold is likely to benefit significantly if the situation worsens. In the meantime, the Bank of Japan (BoJ) released policy minutes last week that highlighted 'extremely high uncertainties' due to global concerns. The bank has lowered its growth and inflation forecasts, worrying that a potential increase in US tariffs could hinder economic recovery. However, its board members have indicated their readiness to raise interest rates if conditions stabilize. As expected, the Bank of England (BOE) decided to keep its policy rate unchanged. Still, one vote leaned towards a dovish stance, with three members supporting a rate cut, while six opted to maintain the current rate. This decision reflects the growing global uncertainties and the rising prices of food and oil. Furthermore, the G7 focused heavily on geopolitical issues and their potential repercussions. Regarding tariffs, they committed to working on a new trade agreement with the US over the next 30 days. Turning to gold, this week it remains in a neutral zone. Much depends on the developments between Iran and Israel. If the situation persists without US intervention, gold prices may decline, but if others become embroiled in the conflict, gold could surge. There's no definitive outlook, making any predictions about gold's next trend speculative. Unless situation eases, bias for gold will remain on the rise. Next week, several important data releases are scheduled, starting with the S&P flash PMI on Monday. On Tuesday, the Consumer Confidence Index will be published alongside Fed Chair Powell's testimony before the House Financial Services Committee. Then on Wednesday, New Home Sales data will be released and Powell will testify before the Senate Banking Committee. On Thursday, the US data to be released will include weekly jobless claims, durable goods orders, and pending home sales, as well as the final Q1 GDP for the US. Finally, on Friday, the PCE Core Inflation for May will be the last data point of the week. WEEKLY OUTLOOK — June 23-27 GOLD @ USD 3368— Gold is expected to remain unstable because of unpredictable circumstances. Only a breakout above USD 3395-00 could lead to a test of USD 3450. However, there is a risk that if it breaks below USD 3322, the fall could extend to USD 3272. EURO @ 1.1525— Support 1.1420 should hold for 1.1610 or 1.1650 before the fall. Otherwise 1.1350. GBP @ 1.3481— Pound Sterling has support at 1.3370 and is not expected to give way. The currency pair needs to rise above 1.3595 in order to reach 1.3640. Or else 1.3320. JPY @ 145.81— The USD has the potential to make some progress, but it must surpass the 146.75-85 range for additional gains. If it fails to do so, a drop below 144.60 could lead to a test of the 143.50 or 142.20 level. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Business Recorder
2 hours ago
- Business Recorder
WHO's stepped up higher tax drive may fuel illicit cigarette trade
LAHORE: As the World Health Organisation (WHO) intensified its global drive for greater tobacco taxes, there are growing concerns in Pakistan that the strategy may have the opposite impact. While intended to reduce smoking, the WHO's tax-centric approach is exacerbating an already rampant illicit cigarette trade, harming legitimate businesses, depleting public cash, and undermining regulatory integrity, experts of the industry said. Pakistan has become a case study of unforeseen effects. Despite heavy taxation in accordance with WHO recommendations, the market has seen a noticeable shift toward illicit cigarette consumption, they said. It may be added that legal tobacco companies now control less than half of the market, although accounting for roughly 98% of the industry's tax revenue. Untaxed and unregulated brands have invaded retail shelves across the country, often selling for less than the legal minimum price and without tax stamps. 'The illicit cigarette trade has now overtaken the legitimate sector, comprising 58% of the total market. Pakistan's annual consumption is around 82 billion sticks, yet only 34 billion are taxed, down sharply from 67 billion a decade ago,' said Asad Shah, Director at Pakistan Tobacco Company (PTC). Shah noted that tax revenue potential from the sector stands at around PKR 570 billion annually, but actual collection reached just PKR 292 billion in FY 2023–24 and only PKR 223 billion in the first 11 months of the current fiscal year. Although the WHO acknowledges illicit trade as a challenge, its policy guidance continues to emphasize taxation over enforcement. 'It's burdening compliant manufacturers while failing to curtail illicit and smuggled brands,' Shah added. Experts said that public health objectives must be pursued alongside strong enforcement mechanisms, not only tax increases. Without this balance, the policy risks facilitating tax evasion, undermining investor confidence, and eroding public trust in the regulatory system. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Business Recorder
2 hours ago
- Business Recorder
Timely completion of energy projects top priority: secy E&P
PESHAWAR: KP Secretary Energy and Power Mohammad Zubair Khan has said that timely completion of the Bala Kot, Lawi and Gurkan, Mataltan, Gabral (Kalam) and Madiyan Hydropower Projects within the stipulated time frame is a major challenge. He expressed these views while presiding over a meeting here the other day. Besides the chief executive officers of Provincial Energy Development Organisation (PEDO), KP Oil and Gas Company and heads of Electric Inspectorate, Energy Planning, Additional Secretary Admin Shoaib Khan and Additional Secretary Power Anwar Khan Sherani, other senior officers also attended the meeting. He stressed on the need to complete the ongoing energy projects in view of the prevailing circumstances and to promote investment in these projects by immediately amending and revising the Power Policy 2016 and issued instructions to prepare work plans, timelines and activity plans to bring transparency in the projects. The secretary Energy and Power said that under the Khyber Pakhtunkhwa government's Good Governance Roadmap Programme, merit and transparency in institutions is the top priority. He said that the biggest challenge is to complete the ongoing energy projects in the Energy & Power department and all its subsidiary institutions within the stipulated time frame in the light of fast track. He said that In light of the directives of the KP chief secretary, it should be the duty of all officers and officials to conduct affairs under e-tendering, e-paid, one-window platform, which will be strictly monitored. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
