Eight years on, Mulcahy Report into alleged planning corruption remains unpublished
The Department of Housing's position on publishing a report into accusations of planning corruption in Donegal has not changed — eight years since its completion.
The Mulcahy Report was completed in June 2017 but has still not been published despite changes in government due to concerns over the nature of the contents and fears that some may be defamatory.
Sources have said only a small number of copies of the report are in circulation.
In 2015, Rory Mulcahy SC was appointed to carry out a review into claims made by whistleblower Gerard Convie, alleging irregularities within the planning department of a local council during the early 2000s.
Rory Mulcahy SC, who was appointed in 2015 to carry out a review into claims made by whistleblower Gerard Convie. File picture: David Keane
Mr Convie had previously contested the findings of an internal review into his claims, which cast doubt on his motivations, by taking legal action in the High Court.
In 2013, the Department of the Environment was compelled to retract that internal review, reverse its conclusions, and issue an apology to Mr Convie.
He had submitted a dossier containing 20 sample cases to the government in 2010, which led then environment minister John Gormley to initiate an independent review.
However, that process was discontinued in 2011 following a change in government.
Mr Gormley's successor, Phil Hogan, instead commissioned an internal review. Completed in 2012, it found no evidence of wrongdoing and questioned Mr Convie's reasons for raising the allegations.
Mr Mulcahy completed his report in June 2017, but it has not yet been made public.
Asked this week if the report might be published, the Department of Housing said its position was unchanged. A statement said: 'The minister is considering the report and will bring this matter to Government for consideration in due course.
'The Attorney General's office has been consulted on both the content of the report and also on the issue of its potential publication and dissemination.
The review is a scoping report and as such it does not make findings as to the truth or otherwise of allegations that have been made by an individual against named persons.
'[T]his is a matter that requires careful consideration given that the scoping report details unproven allegations against named persons.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Independent
6 hours ago
- Irish Independent
Clarity sought on future of 106 west Wicklow social homes
Earlier this month Mr Browne decided to pull the plug on the Public-Private Partnership project that was set to deliver the homes. A total of 486 homes were due to be constructed at sites in Blessington, Dublin, Kildare and Sligo. However, following a review of the costs associated, the Department of Housing, Local Government and Heritage decided earlier this month not to proceed with the contract award on a value for money basis. Following a parliamentary question from Social Democrats TD for Wicklow Jennifer Whitmore, Simon Harris said he has been reviewing the current situation. Speaking in the Dail Mr Harris said he wants to see the project progress. 'I have corresponded directly with the Minister on the matter. We are going to have a review of the national development plan. If the issue is one of funding constraints - it should not be - I am eager that we rectify it in that plan. The review will happen next month.' In response Deputy Whitmore said if funding is the issue, it needs to be restored. 'These homes had full planning permission and were construction ready. The decision to pull the plug on them, without warning, has left the local council and communities in limbo,' Deputy Whitmore stated. 'The Government has cited 'value for money' concerns as the reason for halting the projects – during a housing crisis,' Deputy Whitmore continued. 'How can you justify halting social housing projects at a time when thousands of families are crying out for secure, affordable homes? We need more homes, not less. The Government know this,' Deputy Whitmore added. 'This Blessington development was set to deliver over 100 much-needed homes. This is not just a spreadsheet issue, it's about real people, real families, and real communities. 'The Government must urgently restore funding and provide clarity on the future of these projects,' Deputy Whitmore concluded.
The Journal
7 hours ago
- The Journal
Government survey finds majority of the public think it's doing a bad job on climate
THE LATEST 'CLIMATE Conversations' survey by the government has found that the public believe that the government is seriously underperforming in its climate action. This survey is the fourth report of its kind. It gathered its responses through an online public consultation between May and September 2024. It claims to 'provide critical insights into Irish citizens' attitudes, understanding, and involvement in climate action'. One section of the report, titled 'Perceptions of the Government's Performance [on climate]', summarised its respondents' attitudes to Government's climate performance as so: 'Their performance was generally negatively perceived across all areas, especially in terms of 'having a clear plan in place for getting Government, businesses and people to work together', and in 'Giving citizens a say in climate policy'. 'Supporting individuals and communities to take climate action' was also one of the more poorly rated areas.' Department of the Environment, Climate and Communications Department of the Environment, Climate and Communications Just over one in seven people who responded to the survey believed that the Government is delivering a clear climate action plan. Advertisement The report noted that those that had responded to the online consultation are generally more engaged with the topic of climate change than the general public, and stated 'this is worth remembering' in regards to assessing responses from the cohort in which 76% of the respondents expressed that they felt that they themselves could do more to address climate change, an increase in the previous iterations of the survey. It said that frustration is the dominant emotion felt by the Irish public regarding climate change, followed by worry and powerlessness. Frustration was recorded by 67% of the 1,9,49 respondents (about 1,306 people), worry by 54% (about 1,052 people), and powerlessness by 51% (994 people). Respondents decided that in their view, reducing the number of flights, retrofitting, and the installation of solar panels/wind turbines would have the greatest impact on reducing carbon emissions. However, the department said that there was a misperception and that Ireland's lagging behind on the adoption of electric vehicles was not viewed correctly in this context. Other key findings within the report included the persisting of 'misconceptions' about actions that most effectively reduce carbon emissions. It said that 'many respondents' underestimate the benefits of adopting the use of an electric vehicle. The report recommends establishing community climate hubs, addressing misperceptions about electric vehicles, and enhancing cross-government collaboration on climate initiatives. Minister Darragh O'Brien said that the report 'provides us with a great understanding of the issues that our citizens and communities really care about when it comes to climate action'. Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone... A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article. Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation. Learn More Support The Journal
Sunday World
a day ago
- Sunday World
Sky Ireland issues warning of ‘consequences' for 400,000 dodgy-box users
Warning comes as the broadcaster is set to appear in the High Court after injunction and search order was issued against suspected dodgy-box operator Sky Ireland is warning up to 400,000 dodgy-box users of 'consequences' if caught streaming Sky Ireland is warning up to 400,000 dodgy-box users of 'consequences' if caught streaming sport or films using the illegal devices. The warning comes as the broadcaster, along with other industry bodies, is set to appear in the High Court after an injunction and search order was issued against a suspected operator of a dodgy-box streaming service in Wexford. The alleged operation includes piracy of Sky, Premier Sports, GAA+, LOITV and Clubber, among others, accessed by thousands of Irish dodgy-box owners and multiple resellers. Two additional people associated with the dodgy box operation were also served with cease-and-desist notices by the industry anti-piracy body, Federation Against Copyright Theft (Fact). The notices warned them to stop their 'illicit streaming activities' or face criminal prosecution. An Ireland Thinks poll last year indicated that one in five people in Ireland use dodgy boxes or illegal streaming services. We evolve our investigative strategies to crack down on illegal streaming The devices, sometimes accessed from Amazon Fire Sticks or Android set-top boxes, often involve monthly subscriptions to resellers of the services of between €5 and €15 for illegal access to premium sport and movies. 'This action marks an important step in our ongoing efforts to combat illegal streaming in Ireland,' said Sky Ireland CEO JD Buckley. Sky Ireland CEO JD Buckley. Photo: Sportsfile 'We continuously evolve our investigative strategies to crack down on illegal streaming and protect consumers from risks including malware, fraud and identity theft. Further action will follow with consequences for those identified as operating illegal services and for those who watch them.' Asked about 'consequences', a spokesperson for Sky said it was 'exploring various options', including 'ongoing engagement with the DPC (Data Protection Commissioner)'. Authorities are cracking down on 'dodgy-box' operators An Garda Síochána previously said it did not pursue individual users of dodgy boxes, but it sometimes assisted in action against commercial operators of the services. Earlier this year, Jimmy Doyle, the founder and CEO of Clubber, which shows club and under-age GAA matches from 14 counties, estimated that dodgy boxes were taking up to 40pc of his firm's revenue away. He said the company wants to expand, including covering more female events, but that the use of dodgy boxes is threatening his plans. 'We have a network of local commentators and videographers who rely on Clubber's business to support them and their families,' Mr Doyle said. 'As people use illegal streaming to steal from Clubber, they are putting this entire eco-system at risk.' A survey from Sapir Research this year showed more than two in five people who use dodgy boxes recommend them to friends and family, even though users are more liable to online scams than those who do not use the devices. Illegal streaming directly impacts the investment going into Irish sport Last summer, a 42-year-old Kildare man was jailed for 16 months after making €900,000 from King Kong Media, a dodgy-box operation that sold codes to access pay-TV channels to 5,000 customers. 'We strongly support this decisive action,' Mickey O'Rourke of Premier Sports said about the current High Court action against the Wexford dodgy-box operator. 'Illegal streaming undermines the sustainability of sports broadcasting, directly impacting the investment going into Irish sport, from grassroots to elite level. It also puts consumers at real risk. 'This collaboration between broadcasters, rights holders and authorities is essential to protecting the value of Irish content and ensuring that fans can enjoy their favourite sports through safe and legal channels.' The head of GAA+, Noel Quinn, said pirating of its content hits its grassroots investment levels. 'The GAA reinvests 82 cents of every euro generated directly into schools, clubs, counties and provinces,' he said.
