Lisa Thompson's daughter tells killer's getaway driver she is 'guilty and always will be'

A HSE addiction counsellor, who acted as the get-away driver for "violent and abusive thug" Brian McHugh after he murdered Lisa Thompson, has been told by the victim's daughter that while the defendant tried to paint herself as "the victim" in the trial, she was "guilty and always would be".
The teenager, who was 12 years old when her mother was strangled with a blind cord and stabbed to death in her own home by her former lover, also told Deirdre Arnold: "I hope every time you close your eyes you see what we live with. I hope in the silence of the night it reminds you of how you silenced my mam's voice forever".
Advertisement
On March 10th this year, Brian McHugh (40), with a former address at Cairn Court, Poppintree, Ballymun in Dublin 11, was sentenced to the mandatory term of life imprisonment for murdering 52-year-old Ms Thompson after a jury found he had inflicted 11 stab wounds to her chest and wrapped the cord around her neck.
Six of the wounds had penetrated her heart.
Lisa Thompson (52) was found dead at her home in Sandyhill Gardens in Ballymun on May 10th, 2022. Photo: Family/Garda
In a separate trial last April, a jury found Deirdre Arnold was not an "innocent abroad" and had "decided at every turn" to assist her then-partner McHugh, whom she knew to have murdered mother-of-two Ms Thompson.
Arnold's defence counsel, Mr Patrick Gageby SC, told her sentence hearing on Friday, that "in one of those terrible twists of fate", soon after becoming acquainted with McHugh, the addiction worker herself became addicted to heroin and crack cocaine. He said she has since resigned from her State job.
Advertisement
Arnold, whom the court previously heard is the sole financial support for her three children, remains on bail pending her sentence next month.
Evidence was heard at McHugh's trial that Ms Thompson was dealing prescription drugs from her home, with gardai who searched the house finding thousands of tablets worth nearly €50,000 hidden in the attic. The trial was told that Ms Thompson and McHugh had a "bit of a fling" in the year before she died.
At Arnold's trial, the jury heard that she had made domestic abuse complaints and got an interim barring order against McHugh. She also told gardaí that McHugh had broken her arm by holding it on the bottom of a stairway and stamping on it.
Mr Gageby argued that his client was in fear of McHugh and reminded the jury that, even if they were satisfied she assisted the murderer, for a conviction they had to find it was without reasonable excuse.
Advertisement
The jury unanimously accepted the State's case that Arnold impeded McHugh's prosecution by driving him to Ms Thompson's home at Sandyhill Gardens in Ballymun on May 9th, 2022, where she waited outside for "well over an hour" before driving him away from the scene.
Arnold later checked McHugh into the Clayton Hotel near Dublin Airport in an effort to help him evade prosecution. It was also the prosecution's case that the defendant allowed her silver Hyundai Tucson to be used to dispose of evidence taken from Ms Thompson's home.
Deirdre Arnold, with an address at Briarfield Grove, Kilbarrack, Dublin 5 was charged that on a date between May 9th, 2022, and May 10th, 2022, both dates inclusive, at a location within the State, did without reasonable excuse an act with intent to impede the apprehension or prosecution of Brian McHugh, a person who had committed an arrestable offence, namely murder, whilst knowing or believing Brian McHugh to be guilty of the offence or of some other arrestable offence.
Arnold was also charged that on a date between May 9th, 2022, and May 10th, 2022, both dates inclusive, at a location within the State, acted or embarked upon a course of conduct which had a tendency to and was intended to pervert the course of public justice.
Advertisement
She had pleaded not guilty to the two counts.
'She is truly sorry'
Detective Garda Fergus Burke, of Ballymun Garda Station, told the court on Friday that Arnold has three children and one previous conviction from 2022 for attempting to drive under the influence of drugs. She she received a fine and was disqualified from driving for 18 months for this offence.
In his submissions on Friday, Mr Gageby said Arnold accepted the verdict and the matter would rest there.
He said a letter had been handed up to the court which was not a plea for forgiveness but an indication of "true sorrow for her part" and that she would never forget the consequences of that day.
Advertisement
Counsel added: "She also indicates that she recognises her actions no matter how unintentional had become part of something that caused the family great harm and is truly sorry."
Mr Gageby said his client became a heroin user in early 2020, having formed a relationship with McHugh in the preceding year.
In mitigation, Mr Gageby said there was demonstrably a pattern of abuse in the case and there was a text message deployed by the prosecution in the trial where Arnold had nominated McHugh as a danger to women.
He said there were some unfortunate aspects to Arnold's upbringing and to date she has had three relationships with partners; "none of which had ended well and there seemed to be a pattern".
Mr Gageby said his client had worked from the age of 16, had done a number of courses and had provided counselling.
He added: "In one of those terrible twists of fate, soon after becoming acquainted with Brian McHugh she became herself subject to the addiction of heroin and crack cocaine; a pathetic aspect to this".
The lawyer asked the court to consider if Arnold had not been in a relationship with McHugh at the time, would she ever have offended or come to the attention of authorities or ended up in the Central Criminal Court.
Ireland
Sliabh Liag killers denied legal aid for third bar...
Read More
He said the defendant's conviction is incompatible with State employment and she has resigned.
He said Arnold had worked incredibly hard from the age of 16 to provide a stable home but unfortunately established a relationship with someone who brought her down to his level and she was responsible for that.
He submitted that there is no facility for an open prison for female prisoners and asked the court to take that into consideration.
Mr Justice Patrick McGrath remanded Arnold on continuing bail until July 4th, when she will be sentenced.

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

The Sun

an hour ago

• The Sun

Netflix star Sara Burack's tragic last hours before hit & run death as friend slams cops and begs suspect to speak up

THE best friend of a reality TV star killed in a hit and run on Thursday alleges police have left her family "in the dark" about the motorist who fled the scene. Netflix's Million Dollar Beach House star Sara Burack, 40, was found unconscious by a roadside in The Hamptons in New York shortly before 3 am on Thursday, authorities have confirmed. 4 She was taken to hospital with severe injuries and died hours later surrounded by those closest to her. Sara's close friend Paulette Orlando-Corsair told The U.S. Sun she was with her pal during her final moments and is appealing for help to find the driver. She said, "I don't know what she was doing at the time, she would just galavant, she lives near there and could have been visiting someone. "I don't know if she just stepped out into the street and someone just mowed her down. "At that time of night you're not really thinking a car is gonna come by, maybe she wasn't paying attention. I don't know what happened. "I know people that saw her that night, she was in good spirits. There's no doubt in my mind, she didn't jump in front of a car." Asked about the police investigation, she said, "We've been left in the dark here. "I'm p****ed off at them because she died and it was already written about an hour later, her father didn't even know what was going on, I'm really upset at that. "The father is not well at home alone. I was with her mother at the hospital." Orlando-Corsair also insisted Burack was not pronounced dead shortly after the accident, saying she kept fighting and "lingered on for quite a while." ESPN legend John Brenkus' tragic cause of death aged 54 announced as family make desperate plea "She was on life support and after she was taken off she still lived for another half an hour," her friend continued. 'The doctors said, 'We don't know if she can hear you but you can talk to her.' "We kept on saying, 'Sara, we're here for you, you're not alone.' I wanted her to know she wasn't alone. "It's just sickening. How can you hit someone and just take off like that? "It was a very commercial area, there's several eating establishments, a gas station, all the things. "I don't know if they've found the person yet or they're still looking. They haven't told me anything." Paulette went on, "I'm wondering if it was a drunk driver. The Hamptons is notorious for DWI. That's our crime here. "I would pray that anyone who saw this or knows anything about it to please contact the town of Southhampton police, which is ironically two minutes from where this happened. "They can just walk in there, even if they want to tip anonymously. Leave a paper at the police station." She begged, "Please do it. Someone died in a horrendous way. "Her brain was so damaged, she had multiple fractures, so much swelling, brain bleeding, her liver was damaged, her leg was broken in two places." Both a New York State Police Accident Reconstruction Unit and detectives from the Southampton Town Police Department investigated the scene. The U.S. Sun has made several attempts to contact the Town of Southhampton Police Department. Burack had previously said her family ran a commercial construction and material sales business that she spent years working for before moving into the luxury real estate market. "I have always been intrigued by real estate projects and decided to become a broker after my experience as a summer property manager in the summer house I would rent," she told Burack was a household name for fans of Netflix reality show Million Dollar House, which saw real estate agents pitted against one another. "The competition is fierce - and the drama undeniable - as a group of young and hungry agents try to seal the deal on luxury listings in the Hamptons," according to the description of the show on Netflix's website. Burack had described the show as a glimpse into the lavish lifestyle of the rich and aspiring. "Viewers will be taken into the world of the Hamptons where they will see not only beautiful multimillion-dollar beach homes and estates, but will be shown summer in the Hamptons," she told "With scenes from broker open houses, polo games, yacht life and more, there is sure to be an awww from viewers!" Anyone with information about the crash is asked to call police at 631-702-2230 or 631-728-3400. 4 4

The Independent

2 hours ago

• The Independent

Husband re-arrested in the death of Suzanne Morphew, whose remains were found after 3-year search

The husband of Colorado woman Suzanne Morphew, whose remains were discovered over three years after she was reported missing on Mother's Day 2020, was arrested again Friday on suspicion of first-degree murder, authorities said. Barry Morphew was arrested Friday in Arizona after a Colorado grand jury returned an indictment Wednesday. His bond was set at $3 million, cash only, according to court documents. The district attorney's office said in a statement that it is seeking to bring him back to Colorado. Barry Morphew has maintained his innocence since his wife disappeared, and his attorney David Beller blasted the new indictment. 'Yet again, the government allows their predetermined conclusion to lead their search for evidence,' Beller said in a statement. 'Barry maintains his innocence. The case has not changed, and the outcome will not either.' He was first arrested in his wife's death in May of 2021 on suspicion of first-degree murder, tampering with a human body and other offenses. But prosecutors dropped their case against him the following year just as he was about to stand trial. A judge barred prosecutors from calling key witnesses for repeatedly failing to follow rules for turning over evidence in Barry Morphew's favor. That included DNA from an unknown male that was found in Suzanne Morphew's SUV. At the time, prosecutors said they wanted more time to find her body. Barry Morphew has repeatedly maintained his innocence and previously filed a $15 million lawsuit against county officials, accusing them of violating his constitutional rights. The mystery surrounding Suzanne Morphew began on May 10, 2020, when the 49-year-old mother of two daughters, who lived near the small town of Salida, was reported missing on Mother's Day. Suzanne Morphew's mountain bike and helmet were soon found in separate spots not far from her home, but investigators suspected the bike had been purposefully thrown down into a ravine because there was no indications of a crash. A week after she went missing, Barry Morphew posted a video on Facebook pleading for her safe return. 'No questions asked, however much they want, I will do whatever it takes to get you back,' he said. When he was charged, the arrest affidavit laying out investigators' case against Barry Morphew said his wife insisted on leaving him. He later changed his statements as evidence in the case developed. Morphew, an avid hunter, did not initially tell investigators that he went out of his way as he left for work on Mother's Day, driving toward the place where his wife's bicycle helmet was eventually found. Later, he said he went that way because he had seen an elk cross the road, according to the initial arrest affidavit. After prosecutors dropped the charges against him, Barry Morphew's lawyers announced they had filed a complaint asking that the prosecutors be disciplined for allegedly intentionally withholding evidence in the case. Barry Morphew also filed a $15 million lawsuit against prosecutors and investigators, accusing them of violating his constitutional rights. However, the initial charges against Morphew were dismissed without prejudice, leaving the door open for prosecutors to pursue a case against him later. That happened after Colorado Bureau of Investigation agents stumbled upon Suzanne Morphew's skeletal remains in September 2023 in a shallow grave during an unrelated search near the small southern Colorado town of Moffat, about 40 miles (65 kilometers) south of the Morphews' home. A 2024 autopsy report released said Suzanne Morphew died of 'undetermined means" but ruled it a homicide. A cocktail of drugs that are used to tranquilize wildlife was found in one of her bones but there was no indication of trauma, the report said. A tranquilizer gun and accessories were found in the Morphews' home, according to investigators. ___ Gruver reported from Cheyenne, Wyoming. Associated Press reporter Jaimie Ding in Seattle contributed.

Daily Mail​

2 hours ago

• Daily Mail​

Karen Read haters furious as they spot detail in juror's online bio that 'should have excluded her from the trial'

A juror in the controversial Karen Read trial has sparked outrage after online sleuths spotted alarming details in her X profile. Paula Prado was the 11th of 12 jurors who spectacularly acquitted Read earlier this week over the murder of her Boston cop boyfriend earlier this week. The verdict came Wednesday following two trials which gripped and divided the nation after the first collapsed into a mistrial. Prado said 'justice was served' after Read, 45, was cleared over the January 2022 murder of John O'Keefe. But now a detail in the juror's X bio has sparked concern and accusations of bias, which she was quick to slap down. The short profile states that Prado is a Brazilian attorney and 'true crime lover with a soft spot for justice'. The details have lead many to suggest that Prado should have been recused from jury duty. 'Juror number 11 in the Karen Read trial, already knows she's about to be held in contempt of court for juror fraud & deletes (one of) her X accounts,' one person wrote on X, in reference to Prado. A juror in the controversial Karen Read trial has sparked outrage after online sleuths spotted alarming details in her X profile. In her bio and her pinned post on X, she reveals she is a 'True Crime lover' and a 'licensed attorney in Brazil' sparking allegations of bias Many found these details disqualifying and made posts criticizing her for even agreeing to be on the jury that would let Read go Another wrote that they did not believe Prado, 'knew nothing about [Karen Read] prior to jury selection,' adding that, 'if you knew nothing, how is it one day later you are so informed?' 'So a self-described true crime lover was an unbiased juror in a high profile true crime trial in her backyard?' a third person questioned. Many of the people who posted about this controversy pointed out that Prado appears to be following pro-Karen Read accounts, as well as Aidan Kearney, alias Turtleboy, a journalist who extensively covered the trial. Others were frustrated that in her pinned post, Prado admits she is 'a licensed attorney in Brazil'. While attorneys are called to serve on juries just like any other citizen, they are often struck from the final roster because of how their occupation could influence their approach as a juror. Although Prado had many people attacking her, she had plenty of defenders, mirroring the polarizing nature of the trial itself. One woman replied to one of the posts slamming Prado and claimed that she only started following the various accounts on Thursday, the day after Read was acquitted. Prado then waded in and to try and quash the accusations. 'I am a licensed attorney in Brazil. I do not practice in Massachusetts. When I was asked what I do for work, I answered objectively,' Prado wrote. 'I have an MBA in Marketing and currently support a law office in Brazil with their digital marketing. I hope this clarifies things.' Read was acquitted after jurors rejected the prosecution's argument that she hit her boyfriend with an SUV and left him to die in the snow outside a house party. Her defense put forth a theory that Read was the victim of an elaborate plot to frame her by O'Keefe's law enforcement buddies, some of whom they suggested may have been the true culprits despite no charges being filed against them. In an interview with CBS News, Prado slammed investigators on the Read case for not doing their jobs and proving the allegations beyond a reasonable doubt. 'I just want to tell them it's not our fault that Karen Read was not convicted,' she said. 'Even if there is any chance that she is guilty of something, or hurt him somehow, the Commonwealth or the investigators didn't do their jobs to prove that to us.' Prado said the prosecutors' case was full of inconsistencies and claimed there simply was not enough evidence to definitively conclude that a collision occurred on the day O'Keefe was found dead. Read sobbed in court after she was found not guilty in her second trial. Her first trial ended in July 2024, after a deadlocked jury could not come to a verdict. The jury in her retrial returned a not guilty verdict on the charges of murder and leaving the scene resulting in death on Wednesday. She was found guilty of Operating Under the Influence and sentenced to probation. Read, who wore a light blue suit, cried and hugged her lawyer Alan Jackson after the judge delivered the news. She has long maintained her innocence and insisted that she was framed by his police officer friends who were inside the house where he was found dead. In the years her case has wound through the courts, she managed to gain a cult following of supporters from the widespread social media coverage and hit HBO documentary of the case. Read was greeted by a massive crowd of pink-clad fans shouting 'Karen Read is free' after she left the court an innocent woman. Read thanked her lawyers and supporters in a brief press conference outside of the courthouse. 'I could not be standing here without these amazing supporters who have supported me and my team financially and more importantly emotionally for almost four years,' she said. 'No one has fought harder for justice for John O'Keefe than I have. Than I have, and my team.' The couple had been dating for two years at the time of O'Keefe's death. He had been serving on the Boston Police Department for 16 years. Several witnesses in the case, including some of those who were in the house that fateful night, released a statement calling the verdict a 'miscarriage of justice'. The witnesses who signed the statement included Jennifer McCabe, who made the infamous and misspelled 'Hos long to die in cold' Google search in the early morning hours of O'Keefe's death, and Brian Albert, who owned the home where the party took place. Read's defense claimed that the search was evidence of additional involvement in O'Keefe's death, which was ruled a result of blunt force trauma and hypothermia. 'While we may have more to say in the future, today we mourn with John's family and lament the cruel reality that this prosecution was infected by lies and conspiracy theories spread by Karen Read, her defense team, and some in the media. The result is a devastating miscarriage of justice,' the statement said. Read's supporters told Daily Mail they are ecstatic with the verdict and they are ready to help fight for justice for O'Keefe. 'God, this is just. The American jury system prevailed, and the Commonwealth failed. The Commonwealth failed its people. The jury came back with a just verdict,' said Rita Lombardi, who had been at court nearly every day. 'This is history, and this is what ordinary people did: ordinary people raised their voices in positive and productive ways to speak truth to power. 'My message to the people who did this to John is that you failed miserably. It's just the beginning.' The jury handed down its decision after deliberating for at least 22 hours.