Campaigner hits out at 'PR trick' nuclear energy poll of SNP members
Robin McAlpine, founder of pro-independence think tank Common Weal, has branded the polling a "PR trick based on deliberately withholding crucial information", claiming people who responded were not given "the basic facts".
Polling for the campaign group Britain Remade, founded by a former energy adviser to Boris Johnson, found 52% of those who voted for the party in 2021 believe nuclear power should be included in Scotland's energy mix to meet the 2045 net zero target.
Meanwhile, 57% of those who voted for the party in last year's general election felt the same way, the poll found.
READ MORE: Nigel Farage says he 'doesn't want' NHS to be publicly funded
A total of 56% of Scots thought nuclear power should be part of Scotland's clean energy mix to meet the targets, while 23% disagreed, and 21% said they did not know.
Opinium surveyed 1000 Scottish adults between April 22 and 25.
However, McAlpine argues those quizzed on the topic were not aware of key points as laid out in a blog post for pro-independence Common Weal Common Weal.
He highlights the price of hydrogen electricity being cheaper than nuclear, as well as the hidden costs of building and decommissioning nuclear infrastructure.
"Would SNP voters back nuclear if it was explained that it will cost them three times as much as renewables and then also cost nearly £5000 per household just to clean them up?" McAlpine told The National.
READ MORE: Warning as 100,000 Scots face disruption and higher bills over meter switch off
He further questioned: "Do people know that it is much cheaper to run a renewable system with battery storage for short-term load balancing and hydrogen storage for long term battery storage? Are they aware that you can't turn nuclear power on and off and that it has to run at full power all the time? So it can't balance renewables when the wind isn't blowing, it can only displace renewables from the grid.
"The only conceivable purpose of nuclear in Britain is to power the south of England. Look at Fukushima, look at the power stations in Ukraine, how much risk do you want to take when you have absolutely no need to do it?
"If people are told 'more expensive, much more dangerous, can't be switched up or down or turned off, costs an absolute fortune to decommission at the end', I think you'll find they answer differently."
The SNP have argued nuclear power projects remain too expensive to be a viable alternative to renewable power.
READ MORE: UK wants to build new nuclear plants in Scotland, Ed Miliband says
Responding to the polling, SNP MSP Bill Kidd said: 'Our focus is delivering a just transition that supports communities and creates long-term economic opportunities to build a truly sustainable future.
'Nuclear remains one of the most costly forms of energy with projects like Hinkley Point C running billions over budget and years behind schedule.
'In contrast, Scotland's net zero transition is already delivering thousands of green jobs across energy, construction, innovation, and engineering. This number will continue to grow.
'Simply, renewables are cheaper to produce and develop, create more jobs, and are safer than nuclear as they don't leave behind radioactive waste that will be deadly for generations.
'While Labour funnels billions into slow, centralised projects, the SNP is focused on creating real, sustainable jobs in Scotland now.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scotsman
10 minutes ago
- Scotsman
Fergus Ewing on the 'scunner' factor, falling out with the SNP and spending two hours talking in Morrisons
Sign up to our Politics newsletter Sign up Thank you for signing up! Did you know with a Digital Subscription to The Scotsman, you can get unlimited access to the website including our premium content, as well as benefiting from fewer ads, loyalty rewards and much more. Learn More Sorry, there seem to be some issues. Please try again later. Submitting... Veteran MSP Fergus Ewing has declared the 'signs are right' for his victory as an independent at next year's Holyrood election. Mr Ewing had already said he will not be a candidate for the SNP next year, having represented the party as an MSP since 1999. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad On Friday morning, he announced he would run as an independent in Inverness and Nairn, meaning he will stand against the SNP. First Minister John Swinney said he was saddened by Mr Ewing's decision 'to leave the Scottish National Party'. Fergus Ewing | Colin D Fisher/ Mr Ewing has been a vocal critic of the Scottish Government on several issues, often providing fiery contributions from the back benches. Slow progress on the dualling of the A9 and A96 roads were key to his decision to run as an independent, he said. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Ewing on his victory chances Asked about his chances of victory, Mr Ewing told The Scotsman: 'I've spent 26 years trying to help, assist, support, advocate the interests of people in Inverness and Nairn and we do take a real pride in trying to deal with individual cases as well as can be.' EDINBURGH, SCOTLAND - JUNE 10: Fergus Ewing MSP, Cabinet Secretary for Rural Economy, gives a ministerial statement on tourism during the coronavirus crisis today at the Covid-19 social distancing Scottish Parliament, Holyrood on June 10, 2020 in Edinburgh, Scotland. (Photo by Fraser Bremner-Pool/Getty Images) : Fergus Ewing: "Why were local, worthy candidates rejected?" He added: 'Another aspect is that I think over the past four years, there's been a respect for my stance speaking out on the broken promises, in particular the A9 and the A96.' He was strongly critical of the Scottish Government on this issue. 'If you or I make an honest mistake and do something wrong in life, I think you and I would probably apologise,' he said. 'But they haven't ever acknowledged their faults. 'Where there should be honesty, there is hubris. Where there should be humility, there is denial.' Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Mr Ewing said he has strong local support. 'Two Fridays ago, it took me two hours to get through Morrisons to do some shopping for four items, and I wasn't swithering in the aisles,' he said. 'It was just people wanting to speak to me. 'It's easy to overestimate one's own personal popularity, but I did get a majority of around nine [thousand] or 10,000 for the past three elections and I think I'm in with for a shout. But let the people decide. 'I'm certainly going to put everything into it, as I have done before.' Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad The 'scunner' factor Mr Ewing said there was also a 'scunner' factor which may benefit him. 'People are scunnered with both governments at the moment, and that's why Reform is picking up votes with no known leaders in Scotland whatsoever,' he said. 'So I think the signs are propitious. The signs are right.' He said he was still a member of the SNP. 'Whether or not they take action is up to them,' he said. 'I'm waiting with some curiosity. 'But if you think about it, it's not me that's broken the policy on the A9 and the A96. It's not me that no longer believes that it's Scotland's oil. It's not me that's turned the back on the workers in Grangemouth, and did very little, very late. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad 'It's not me that's let down rural Scotland. It's not me that's broken all those policies that we had championed in the interests of the people in Scotland.' The SNP said its constitution states membership ceases when an individual declares their intention to stand against the party. Ewing's family links to SNP Mr Ewing is the son of nationalist trailblazer Winnie Ewing and previously served as a minister. Winnie Ewing (right), arriving in London with her children, Fergus, Terry and Annabelle, in 1967 | Getty Images Since leaving government, he has criticised SNP ministers on a range of issues, including the decision to bring the Greens into the Scottish Government in the Bute House Agreement, which collapsed last year. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Emma Roddick has been selected as the SNP candidate for Inverness and Nairn. In 2021, Mr Ewing won the seat for the SNP with a majority of 9,114. John Swinney's response SNP leader Mr Swinney said: 'It was with real sadness and deep regret that I heard of Fergus Ewing's decision to leave the Scottish National Party. First Minister John Swinney addressing the Scotland 2050 conference in Edinburgh | PA 'We have both served the SNP and the cause of independence for many years, and I commend him for all that he achieved while serving in the SNP Government until 2021. 'Fergus had the option of standing at the forthcoming election for the SNP, given his status as an approved candidate. He chose not to accept that opportunity and I regret that he has ultimately decided instead to leave the party. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad
The National
24 minutes ago
- The National
Scottish Government removes WhatsApp from all official devices
Deputy First Minister Kate Forbes announced the move on Friday, following an externally led review that concluded in December 2024. The new policy means that all Scottish Government employees will now be allowed to install WhatsApp or other similar messaging platforms on government devices. This rule will apply to ministers, special advisors, senior civil servants, and contractors working for the Scottish Government. READ MORE: JK Rowling called The National 'anti-woman' – here's my response Several Government agencies and departments will be allowed a 'transition period' until the end of 2025. The review was led by former Channel Islands data protection commissioner Emma Martins. Martins has made 20 recommendations on different areas of corporate governance, including the values of the Scottish Government, learning and development process, recruitment procedures, records management and the use of mobile messaging apps. 'We are setting out a clear approach to ending government use of mobile messaging apps, and this will support wider work to deliver on our commitment to openness and transparency,' Forbes said. (Image: Andrew Milligan) 'The use of mobile messaging apps increased during the pandemic as staff worked remotely in unprecedented and difficult circumstances. Having reflected on our working practices, we are now implementing changes to the use of such apps. 'This follows on from actions to implement other recommendations from Ms Martins' externally-led review including updating our hybrid working policy. 'I want to reassure the public that it is a priority of this government to maintain secure and searchable data, ensuring compliance with all records management rules. We will continue to act to ensure our data policies are robust, especially considering technological advances.' In response to a written question in the Scottish Parliament, Forbes set out the departments and agencies that will be allowed to use mobile messaging apps until the end of the year. READ MORE: SNP MSP Fergus Ewing to stand as independent in Holyrood election This includes agencies Forestry and Land Scotland, Science Advice for Scottish Agriculture, Animal and Plant Health Agency, Food Standards Scotland. Departments include the Rural Payments and Inspection Directorate, communication staff, news staff only, 'for communications purposes', Culture and External Affairs Directorate, EU Directorate and the Directorate of International Trade and Investment. Forbes said certain organisations had 'no practical alternative' during emergencies, such as tackling wildfires, communicating with the media or 'overseas operational tasks'. It comes after WhatsApp messages deleted by ministers and officials during the Covid-19 pandemic were raised by the subsequent inquiry. Jamie Dawson KC, lead counsel to the UK Covid-19 Inquiry, previously said most of the messages sent within the Scottish Government had been deleted. It later transpired a number of senior members of the Government, including John Swinney and Nicola Sturgeon, had deleted messages, though both stressed they did not relate to Government business. Former national clinical director Jason Leitch was also criticised for describing deleting WhatsApp messages as a 'pre-bed ritual', while another senior clinician warned colleagues that messages could be published under freedom of information legislation.
Scotsman
an hour ago
- Scotsman
Cammy Day accused of 'drunken tirade' that left fellow Labour councillor in tears
Former council leader Cammy Day has been accused of subjecting a fellow Labour councillor to a 'drunken tirade' at a Christmas party that left her in tears. Sign up to our daily newsletter Sign up Thank you for signing up! Did you know with a Digital Subscription to Edinburgh News, you can get unlimited access to the website including our premium content, as well as benefiting from fewer ads, loyalty rewards and much more. Learn More Sorry, there seem to be some issues. Please try again later. Submitting... Councillor Katrina Faccenda said she '[does] not welcome' Cllr Day's return to the party's group, as Edinburgh Council agreed steps to address the council's 'culture of hospitality' – including drinking events on city property – and to improve the process of handling complaints against councillors. These were part of the recommendations from an independent report into the city's handling of misconduct allegations against Cllr Day, who attended the meeting remotely. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Cammy Day has been cleared by police of inappropriate behaviour | TSPL Cllr Faccenda said: 'I have been subjected to a drunken tirade by Councillor Day that actually forced me to leave a Christmas party in tears.' She also said that issues in the party had led her to sleepless nights, and that she had considered not attending Thursday's full council meeting due to Cllr Day's possible presence. Cllr Day resigned as council leader in December last year over allegations that he had sent unwanted inappropriate messages to two Ukrainian refugees. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad He was also administratively suspended by the Labour Party, pending an investigation. The council agreed to hold an investigation into the city's handling of misconduct complaints against him and other councillors and commissioned former Scottish information commissioner Kevin Dunion to carry it out. Mr Dunion's report, debated by councillors on Thursday, found that the city had 'inadequately' handled complaints into Cllr Day's behaviour. It further suggested that the council's 'culture of hospitality' – including drinking events on city property – needed to be addressed. Councillors have agreed to take action on recommendations made by the Dunion Report, including reforms to the city's whistleblowing system and improving safeguarding in the council. Cllr Day was recently readmitted to the Labour Party and the council's Labour group after a police investigation cleared him of criminal wrongdoing. And an investigation by Labour cleared him to return to the party. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad SNP group leader Simita Kumar said the report revealed a 'deeply troubling catalogue of allegations against Councillor Day'. 'The report references several instances and a number of individuals over a significant period of time,' she said. 'I am appalled to read the complainant's disclosures were dismissed as gossip. 'While councillor Day's actions may not have crossed a criminal threshold, his conduct is not compatible with the standards expected of us.' And she said the decision to readmit Cllr Day to the Labour Party was 'rushed and reckless', adding: 'This is a Labour group that have abandoned their moral compass.' Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Earlier in the meeting, council leader Jane Meagher strongly affirmed that she welcomed the findings of the Dunion Report, which investigated the handling of reports against Cllr Day. SNP group leader Simita Kumar asked Cllr Meagher if she'd seen the full contents of the report. Cllr Meagher replied: 'As you know, as council leader, I take all complaints seriously. The party investigates all complaints in line with their rules and procedures. 'These investigations are done by specially trained staff in the party's governance and legal units. Quite rightly, I am not privy to any details of the Labour Party's deliberations. 'I do know that, after an investigation by the Labour Party, Cllr Day's administrative suspension has been lifted, and no conditions were attached. I look forward to working with Cammy again.'
