The Terrible Burden of Actually Watching Oscar Contenders
There's faking it 'til you make it, and then there's faking it for years after you've already made it. Some Oscar voters who've long since made it into the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences have apparently embraced the latter. Last month, the elite film-industry group announced a new rule for the final round of voting for next year's Oscar winners. Academy members must now watch all of the films before casting their ballots—all of them, all the way through.
That might seem like an obvious rule for voters of any award: View the works you're judging. But when I recently spoke with several Academy members about the new condition, the lack of consensus about how to judge a movie was striking.
'I am the first one to be on that list of people who don't watch everything,' one film editor in the Academy told me. (All of my interview subjects in the Academy requested anonymity to speak candidly about their own behavior or the Academy's conduct.) ' Wicked is totally uninteresting. I know I'm not going to vote for it, and I didn't really watch it,' she added, referring to the Wizard of Oz prequel that was nominated for Best Picture this year. 'I can only watch the things I'm interested in. Otherwise, for me, it's a waste of my time.' The new rule won't change her habits, she told me. 'I know what I like. I know what I don't like. If I start it and watch 10, 15 minutes and know I'm not going to vote for it, I'll just continue 'Play,' but I might not watch it. I'm just gonna walk away.'
What exactly have the Academy's voting members been doing for the past nearly 100 years? Members have been encouraged to give all nominees a fair shake, but—aside from a few specialized categories—were not explicitly required to see a movie in competition from opening sequence to closing credits. Under the new system, to have their final-round ballots unlocked and counted, voters will have to either watch each nominee from start to finish via the Academy's private screening app or complete a form attesting to where and when they saw the film (if at an external venue).
David Sims: The Oscars have left the mainstream moviegoer behind
Some members I spoke with pointed out that the rule reform lacked teeth—if voters are willing to lie about having seen a movie at a festival or at the theater. 'The Academy can't track you,' one director in the Academy told me, 'and you can just tick it off.' The Academy's app isn't foolproof either. Voters can leave the movie running while cooking dinner or answering emails. But the point is that the Academy's honor system will now include the jeopardy of dishonor for cheating—given the theoretical risk of being caught in a lie.
One documentarian in the Academy told me that some tightening up was needed, but requiring voters to sit through all of the films in full was asking too much: 'Filmmakers know very quickly whether something that they're watching is really special,' he told me. 'What is watching a film? Is it watching the first 25 minutes of a film? Does that count? Or do you have to get all the way through?' If we decide to award an Oscar for the Best Opening 25 Minutes, perhaps we can all agree that Saving Private Ryan deserves one retroactively.
Other members disagreed that filmmakers can distinguish greatness from mediocrity so quickly. The new rule should have come out a 'long time back,' the director told me. So why did the update come only now? 'Not a lot of people saw The Brutalist in its entirety,' he said. The film took home three Academy Awards. Perhaps some of the Academy's members felt they didn't need to sit through the three-and-a-half-hour run time (plus a 15-minute intermission in theaters) and come to an independent view of their own, because the Golden Globes voters had already garlanded the film with three of their biggest awards a few weeks before the Oscars. (The Academy declined my request for comment.) 'The year-end films are Oscar-bait movies,' the director said—meaning they come late enough to be fresh in the voters' memory but early enough to accrue critical buzz.
'I made it through 45 minutes,' another documentary maker in the Academy told me. Watching it was 'a big ask.' A composer in the Academy, one of two I spoke with, told me that voters skipping the hours-long Brutalist was an open secret among his peers: 'Several people were like, 'I can't. I started it and I couldn't finish.'' Its success considering its scant viewership 'was definitely a head-scratcher to me and most of my friends,' he said.
The Brutalist was not the first film in Academy history to win more acclaim than viewing minutes. According to the director I spoke with, the 2022 four-Oscar winner All Quiet on the Western Front was also scarcely watched by voters. Nodding off early makes for a reliable verdict too. 'I fell asleep during Conclave,' the documentary maker confessed.
The obvious question: How do movies that many Academy members find unwatchable end up being nominated for, or even winning, the highest honors in the industry? From my conversations with Academy members, one answer emerged: If not everyone who votes has time—or makes time—to watch every movie in full, an army of publicists is ready to capitalize on time-crunched voters' suggestibility.
The 2025 Best Picture winner, Anora, made headlines after its studio spent a good chunk of its $18 million marketing budget—triple the film's $6 million production cost—on its Oscars campaign, which included selling a line of film-branded red thongs. Generating word-of-mouth excitement among a body of 10,000 movie insiders is an expensive but crucial part of the game. The other composer in the Academy I spoke with told me that bigger-budget films have been known to co-host a private concert for Oscar voters at L.A.'s Royce Hall theater that is essentially 'a cocktail party with drinks and hors d'oeuvres' to showcase their nominated score's composer. 'You're basically at a campaign rally for very few films,' he said.
The first composer told me that 'when Barbie was a nominee, the year before last, Warner Bros. put on so many events.' He offered a blunt appraisal of how Academy voting works: 'It certainly isn't whether or not we watch the films. It's the extent to which we are being wined and dined'—then adding, 'Not wined and dined, but given access.' Particularly in determining votes for more niche award categories, film publicists play a big role. 'There's so much competition,' he said. Some people would consider the choices 'overwhelming, and want to be told what to vote for.' (Members are not, of course, under any obligation to vote in every category.)
Although Academy members tended to see the rule change as a housekeeping fix, online cynics read it as a confession of fraud and corruption. The controversy has put a spotlight on the gap between what the Oscars strives to be and what it actually is. Instead of celebrating what makes cinema great, it's made intra-Hollywood intrigue visible to the general public. 'What's fascinating,' William Stribling, a filmmaker who is not an Academy member, told me, 'is that the public and moviegoing audiences are so heavily invested in this thing, which is really an internal, industry-celebrating-industry event.'
By trying to make the Oscars fairer, the Academy inadvertently revealed that the award business hasn't been all that fair to begin with. But perhaps that's Hollywood's worst-kept secret already.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
3 hours ago
- Yahoo
NEWS OF THE WEEK: Ariana Grande mourns death of grandma at 99
The Wicked star reshared a heartbreaking statement posted by her mother, Joan Grande, about Marjorie's death. "We are devastated to share that the beloved matriarch of our family has passed away," the statement signed by Grande and her family reads. "Marjorie (Nonna) Grande passed away peacefully in her home and was surrounded by family and loved ones for every moment of her last few weeks. We thank you for your love, support, and for respecting our privacy as we grieve and celebrate her beautiful, extraordinary life." Grande and her grandmother shared a close bond.
UPI
4 hours ago
- UPI
'Wicked,' 'Thundermans,' 'Cobra Kai' win top Kids' Choice Awards
1 of 5 | Tyla attends the 2025 Nickelodeon's Kids' Choice Awards at Barker Hangar in Santa Monica, Calif., on Saturday. Photo by Greg Grudt/UPI | License Photo June 22 (UPI) -- Wicked was named Favorite Movie and its star Ariana Grande was voted Favorite Movie Actress at the Kids' Choice Awards in Santa Monica Saturday night. Jack Black earned the Favorite Movie Actor honor for Minecraft. In the TV categories, The Thundermans was deemed Favorite Kids TV Show, while its stars Jack Griffo and Kira Kosarin won for Favorite Male and Female TV Star (Kids) respectively. Cobra Kai cast-mates Xolo Maridueña and Peyton List took home the prizes for Favorite Male and Female TV Star (Family). XO, Kitty won for Favorite Family TV Show, America's Got Talent won for Favorite Reality TV Show and SpongeBob SquarePants won for Favorite Cartoon. SZA was voted Favorite Female Music Artist, Bruno Mars won for Favorite Male Music Artist and Stray Kids scored the Favorite Music Group trophy. Tyla hosted the Nickelodeon event, which also saw Black presented with the King of Comedy life-achievement award and Rihanna with the ICON Silver Blimp Award. Stars arrive at the Nickelodeon Kids' Choice Awards Tyla attends the 2025 Nickelodeon's Kids' Choice Awards at Barker Hangar in Santa Monica, Calif., on June 21, 2025. She hosted the show. Photo by Greg Grudt/UPI | License Photo
USA Today
5 hours ago
- USA Today
'Elio' star Zoe Saldaña lives for winning 'cool mom points' with her kids
How does Zoe Saldaña follow up an Academy Award win? By starring in a Pixar animated movie. Her kids think one is cooler than the other, and it might not be the one you expect. 'Definitely winning an Oscar, because they're playing soccer right now,' Saldaña says. 'They're like, 'Mom! Oscar is like the World Cup!' And then my third son was like, 'What? You got it for supporting actress, right?' And I'm just like, 'Oh, Zen. Thank you for keeping me on my toes.' 'But they're always proud of the fact that I'm making an effort in wanting to cater to films that they can watch right now.' Join our Watch Party! Sign up to receive USA TODAY's movie and TV recommendations right in your inbox Saldaña has starred in big franchises like 'Guardians of the Galaxy' and 'Avatar' but also stayed busy in the animation space, with roles in the 'Maya and the Three' miniseries, 'Missing Link,' 'My Little Pony: The Movie' and now Pixar's 'Elio.' Saldaña voices Olga Solis, the aunt and guardian of an 11-year-old boy named Elio (Yonas Kibreab) who wishes he could be abducted by aliens and is picked up by a spaceship full of colorful creatures. The "Emilia Pérez" star always wants her sons – twins Cy and Bowie, 10, and Zen, 8 – to be proud of her, and 'my kids are absolutely revelations to me every single day,' Saldaña says. 'They're my biggest teachers. And obviously I say that behind their backs. I never want them to feel completely responsible for my growth, but they are teaching me a lot by just growing around me and evolving and setting their boundaries and claiming their space and revealing themselves to themselves.' By being in stories that appeal to younger audiences, 'it just contributes to my deeper education on wanting to know how to be a better mom to my kids,' she adds. 'I just want to be cool for a longer time than possible. In my mind, I feel like that this gives me cool mom points.' Her character in 'Elio,' though, has to figure out how to be a mom. Olga is an Air Force major who's put her dreams of being an astronaut on hold to care for her nephew, and they struggle to get along. When Elio gets beamed up to space and goes on his adventures there, a clone Elio is sent back to Earth to take his place. And this one, Elio 2.0, is agreeable, generally compliant and overall 'too perfect,' Saldaña says. 'That sounds in theory like a perfect Mother's Day, where the mom has a yes day,' Saldaña says. 'Can I make you some broccoli with that? Yes. Do you want to pick up after yourself? Absolutely. But if that were to happen in reality in my life, I would be like at the hospital with my kids, like there's something wrong with my child. Why he's saying yes to everything I'm proposing?! 'With Olga, even though everything on the surface was fine, something was unsettling. That woke up that maternal instinct in her to, to really say, 'OK, I may not understand my kid, but I love my kid so much so that I know when he's off, I know when he's not being himself.' ' Saldaña, who next stars in "Avatar: Fire and Ash" (in theaters Dec. 19), enjoys collaborating with kids on movie projects. 'It's shorter work hours when you work with children,' she says. 'You don't have to do those long 14-hour days. If all your scenes are with that child, you get to go home when they go home and I kind of love that. 'It's easier for me to work with other kids than to work with my own. I can't really imagine ever being able to work with my own kids because I wouldn't be able to separate being their mom at all times.' A couple of Saldaña's sons have expressed some interest in acting. She and husband Marco Perego 'would support our children if this is what they would want to pursue," Saldaña says. "But so far, the moment we go, 'Well, come on, let's wake up at 4 o'clock in the morning, let's get on the road for two hours, let's memorize these 10 pages,' they're like, 'Uh, I don't think so.' '
