BBC's 'pattern of bias' on Gaza and clash with Scottish minister

Welcome to this week's Media Watch. Remember you can sign up to receive this newsletter for free every week by clicking the banner above.
Fresh report on BBC 'bias' in Gaza coverage
We have been covering accusations of bias over the BBC's reporting of Israel's assault on Gaza for some time now, and a fresh report has now found the broadcaster has demonstrated 'double standards and the silencing of Palestinian voices'.
The Centre of Media Monitoring (CfMM) analysed the BBC's coverage of Israel's war on Gaza between October 7 2023 and October 6 2024, looking at 3873 articles and 32,092 broadcast segments.
Despite there being 34 times more Palestinian deaths, the CfMM found this was not reflected in the number of victim profiles the BBC ran for Palestinians (279) and Israelis (201).
During the timeframe analysed by the CfMM, 42,010 Palestinians and 1246 Israelis were killed. The death toll in Gaza has now reached more than 55,000 Palestinians, many of whom were women and children.
READ MORE: Rest of Madleen crew released after being detained by Israel
The report also found that the BBC interviewed twice as many Israelis as Palestinians when reporting on Gaza. During the analysis period, the BBC interviewed 2350 Israelis compared to 1085 Palestinians.
The CfMM said that while the BBC asked 38 guests to condemn Hamas, it asked zero to condemn Israel's mass killing of civilians.
The report concluded there is 'a pattern of bias' in the BBC's coverage.
Despite Israel being credibly accused of committing genocide in Gaza, the CfMM said BBC presenters interrupted or dismissed genocide claims more than 100 times, yet made no mention of genocidal rhetoric used by Israeli leaders.
Further, the term "war crimes" in relation to Israeli violence against Palestinians was mentioned in only 121 BBC articles analysed – just 3 per cent of the total.
When the BBC was asked about the report, it said there appeared to have been 'some reliance on AI' to analyse language adding 'we do not think due impartiality can be measured by counting words'.
(Image: AP Photo/Abdel Kareem Hana) 'We make our own, independent editorial decisions, and we reject any suggestion otherwise,' a spokesperson said.
The report comes after Dr Tom Mills, who analysed the corporation in The BBC: Myth of a Public Service in 2016, collected data via Nexis UK earlier this year to determine how often the International Court of Justice (ICJ) or International Criminal Court (ICC) is mentioned in BBC news reports in relation to Israel and Gaza coverage.
Mills found the bodies were "almost never" mentioned. In more than 200 BBC1 reports he collected mentioning Israel and Gaza between February 20 and March 19 this year, the institutions were only mentioned five times.
This is despite the ICJ saying Israel is under an obligation to end its unlawful presence in the Occupied Palestinian Territories as rapidly as possible, cease all new settlement activities, evacuate settlers, and make reparations for damages caused.
Scottish minister clashes with BBC presenter
Elsewhere, SNP minister Gillian Martin has clashed with a BBC Radio Scotland presenter over Scottish independence.
The Cabinet Secretary for Climate Action and Energy appeared on Radio Scotland on Monday morning and dismissed claims that the First Minister John Swinney had not spoken with the Prime Minister about Scottish independence.
She appeared on the show to discuss the Scottish Government's plans on how to mitigate waste when "black bag" waste is banned from being buried in landfills at the end of the year.
READ MORE: UK must 'constrain Israel' after attacks on Iran, John Swinney says
According to the BBC, up to 100 truckloads of Scotland's waste could be transported each day to England once a landfill ban comes into effect. However, Martin argued that the measure was only temporary while local authorities adjusted to the change in waste policy.
Shortly after this discussion, Radio Scotland host Laura Maxwell changed the topic towards independence as she highlighted that Swinney is set to deliver a speech in Edinburgh on Tuesday outlining how self-determination could achieve Scotland's long-term goals.
After saying that independence was the right route forward for Scotland, Maxwell then interrupted Martin, asking: 'In a couple of sentences, just lay out how the current government plans to achieve independence.'
Martin replied: 'Scottish independence will happen when the majority of people in Scotland want it.'
However, Martin was again only seconds into her reply when Maxwell cut her off again by saying: 'That's the political argument, but actually doing it, how do you plan to achieve it?'
Martin replied: 'It is an untenable situation for the UK Government to deny democracy to the people of Scotland.
'If they vote for independence-promoting parties, then there has to be a rethink.'
Martin also suggested she did not believe Keir Starmer when said Swinney had not broached the subject with independence with him.

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

NBC News

an hour ago

• NBC News

U.S. braces for Iran's response after strikes on nuclear sites: Weekend Rundown

The United States is bracing for Iran's response after President Donald Trump launched punishing strikes on Iranian nuclear energy sites Saturday. It was the first time the U.S. has directly bombed the Islamic Republic. The U.S. struck Iranian nuclear facilities, including the key Fordo site, with 14 GBU-57s, 30,000-pound 'bunker buster bombs,' according to the U.S. military. On Sunday, Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth said that while the U.S. did not want war, it will 'act swiftly and decisively when our people, our partners or our interests are threatened.' The few days are of particular concern, according to two defense officials and a senior White House official. It's unclear whether any retaliation would target overseas or domestic locations, or both, the officials said. While Iranian Foreign Minister Abbas Araghchi warned of 'everlasting consequences,' experts say the country has limited options. Constraints Iran's capacity to strike is narrower than it once was. H.A. Hellyer, a senior associate at the London-based Royal United Services Institute, told NBC News that Iran still has the power to attack, 'but only because Israelis haven't taken out all of their missile launchers.' Iran still has around 40% of its launchers, Hellyer said. Iran's proxy network has also been battered by years of attrition with Israel and the U.S. Its most important ally, Hezbollah in Lebanon, has indicated it would not join the fight against Israel. Iran may also lack staunch support from its neighbors — some Gulf nations stopped short of condemning the U.S. attacks on Iran, calling instead for de-escalation. Cyber threats The Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps' cyber capabilities are formidable, and the U.S. considers Iran one of its four major adversaries in cyberspace along with China, North Korea and Russia. While Iran lacks Russia's robust cybercrime syndicates or China's vast teams of sophisticated digital spies, the U.S. has in recent years accused Iranians of working for the IRGC. If Iran conduct retaliatory cyberattacks, they would come in the wake of several rounds of cuts to the Trump administration's top civilian cyber defense agency, the Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency. CISA's two former directors have both warned that the administration's cuts make U.S. infrastructure more vulnerable to hackers. 'Meet the Press' Vice President JD Vance said the U.S. is not at war with Iran, but with Tehran's nuclear weapons program. During an interview on NBC News' 'Meet the Press,' moderator Kristen Welker asked the vice president whether the U.S. was now at war with Iran. 'We're not at war with Iran,' Vance said. 'We're at war with Iran's nuclear program.' Vance also declined to confirm with 100% confidence that the country's nuclear sites had been completely destroyed. Sen. Lindsey Graham, R-S.C., meanwhile, brushed off concerns that Trump had acted without authorization from Congress. 'Congress can declare war or cut off funding. We can't be the commander in chief. You can't have 535 commander in chiefs,' Graham said, referring to the number of representatives and senators. But Sen. Mark Kelly, D-Ariz., said that the president can act militarily 'when there's a clear and imminent threat to U.S. citizens, to the United States, to the homeland.' 'That wasn't the case here,' Kelly said. Politics in brief Flip-flop: Across the country, 20-point margins in counties Republicans were winning at the turn of the century have turned into 50-point margins or more in recent years. Political competitiveness at the local level is being replaced by landslide loyalty to a single party. Fighting on: After more than three months in ICE detention, Columbia University student Mahmoud Khalil returned to the New York area, where his harrowing ordeal first began — and vowed to keep speaking out against the war in Gaza. Well, that's 'awkward': Former Chicago Mayor Rahm Emanuel is considering a run for president in 2028, and admits the potential of taking on his friend and ally Illinois Gov. JB Pritzker is 'going to be awkward.' War on porn brings together strange bedfellows Feminists, religious crusaders and 'alpha male' influencers are unlikely allies in the decades-old battle over adult content — and they're on a winning streak. Anti-porn campaigners have pushed states into implementing online age verification laws, while some politicians are pursuing aggressive bans on explicit content. Culturally, the view that porn is harmful not only to women but increasingly also to men and to the sexual development of young people has made significant inroads. Once viewed as a fringe moral crusade, the war against porn has ballooned into a multipronged, mainstream force over the past decade. Porn industry leaders have acknowledged their ongoing battle with deepfakes, underage content and revenge porn, including Pornhub, which removed millions of unverified videos from its website in 2020 following allegations that the site showed problematic content. Gail Dines, a key figure in the anti-porn movement for over 30 years, said the goal isn't necessarily to ban porn, but argued the industry has 'sowed the seeds of its own destruction.' NBA to crown its champion in Game 7 It all comes down to this. The NBA Finals. Game 7. The Larry O'Brien Championship Trophy on the line. After a postseason filled with memorable games (and a handful of wild Indiana Pacers comebacks), the NBA will decide its champion when the Oklahoma City Thunder and star Shai Gilgeous-Alexander host Tyrese Haliburton and the Pacers at the Paycom Center. NBC News will be covering Game 7 live from OKC. . Notable quote I think their parents did not raise them well enough. Esther Yang, New York City yoga instructor A cast of scandal-plagued candidates is testing the limits of what New York City voters will forgive, with Andrew Cuomo, Eric Adams and Anthony Weiner bringing no shortage of baggage to their political campaigns this year. In case you missed it A shooter at a Michigan church injured one person Sunday before being shot and killed by a security guard, according to local authorities. A hot-air balloon caught fire and tumbled from the sky on Saturday in Brazil's southern state of Santa Catarina, killing eight people. At least three people are dead in rural North Dakota after tornadoes left damage across eastern areas of the state, the Cass County Sheriff's Office said Saturday. The Phoenix Suns are reportedly trading forward Kevin Durant to the Houston Rockets in exchange for Jalen Green, Dillon Brooks, the 10th pick in this week's NBA draft and a slew of future picks. Fred Smith, the FedEx Corp. founder who revolutionized the express delivery industry, has died, the company said. He was 80. In Indianapolis, which is home to around 30,000 Burmese people, a travel ban and tariffs on goods from Myanmar have hit local businesses hard. Dozens of people suffered minor injuries when a yacht carrying 352 passengers crashed into a pier on the Hudson River in New York City, authorities said.

ITV News

an hour ago

• ITV News

'We can finally see the light': Iranian activists stand in solidarity with Israel after US strikes

Iranian activists opposing the country's rulers said they were "happy the regime has been attacked" as they gathered outside the Iranian embassy in London on Sunday. Less that 24 hours after the US airstrikes on Iranian nuclear sites, around 500 activists chanted in unison, "long live Iran, long live Israel." With both Iranian and Israeli flags on show, activists showed a united front saying they were "grateful" to Israel for attacking the "oppressive" Iranian regime with one activist saying "let the bombs fall." The peaceful protest was in stark contrast to another gathering held on Friday which resulted in seven men being charged after two people were injured with serious but not life-threatening injuries. "We can finally see the light" - Niaz Malhania, Iranian activist Iranian activist Niaz Malhania said: "The message here today is that we are really happy that the Islamic Republic [of Iran] has been attacked and destabilised after 46 years. "Iranians are standing with Israel because we can finally see the light, freedom for the Iranian people. Our human rights have been eroded over decades. "This is the closest we'll ever get to the regime falling. If it doesn't fall now after this, it'll never fall. "With President Trump attacking again last night, it really is destabilising. But overall I'm happy, we're happy." The United States has directly joined Israel's conflict with Iran - with Donald Trump confirming the US military launched successful strikes on three Iranian nuclear sites. In response to last night's airstrikes, the Iranian Foreign Minister, Abbas Araghchi, said the US and President Trump had crossed "a big red line" and warned that it would have "everlasting consequences". Iranian national Nazak Tavakoli is a dentist who moved to London from Iran 30 years ago. With friends and family back at home, Ms Tavakoli said: "Nobody wants war, but the fact is we cannot stop until we have a regime change in Iran. "It's a terrorist regime that has caused so much havoc all over the world but they terrorise their own people. "It's such an oppressive establishment, it's horrendous." "We want a democratic society where Iranian people are free. Israel's attacks mean this could be our golden ticket, to overthrow the people in power," she added. Pouya Rad, now living in the UK, said he suffered directly in the hands of the Iranian regime. Speaking to ITV News, Mr Rad became emotional reflecting on the seven months he endured as a political prisoner. Mr Rad said: "As a political prisoner, I have been hurt. I want to be the voice of my people who are being executed and tortured. "I still have family who live back home, and I want to be their voice." As countries across the world continue to react to the US strikes on Iran, the group Iran Javidan, plan to hold another protest outside Parliament on Tuesday.

ITV News

2 hours ago

• ITV News

Israelis describe sky as a battleground as Iranian missiles hit Tel Aviv

A missile strike launched by Iran hit buildings in Tel Aviv on Sunday as Israelis describe the sky above their homes as a battelground. ITV News' Debi Edward reports When we stood at the site of a missile strike in the heart of Tel Aviv on Thursday, the people we spoke to were impatient for the United States to get involved in Israel's war against Iran. Now that American bombers have dropped their bombs, for many it is "about time" and there is a presumption, or hope at least, that the US involvement, namely it's hard-hitting weapons, will help bring a faster conclusion to this others, who are growing weary of the daily dread they face from Iranian air strikes, they fear President Trump has put them in greater danger. People here had been told that the Iranians would quickly run out of missiles, that their launchers had mostly been destroyed, yet every day, or night, the skies above of Israel become a battleground. In recent days there have been more than a few ballistic missiles able to breach the country's sophisticated the whole support for the war, and anti-Iran sentiment, is strong, and now the President Trump has thrown his weight behind Prime Minister Netanyahu, that support has only prime minister looked almost gleeful in a video message thanking Donald Trump for what he said was his '"bold decision" to bomb Iran's nuclear facilities. He claimed it was Trump's leadership that would create a pivot in history and lead to peace in the Middle the short term, peace seems like an elusive state in both Israel and Iran, where the people of each nation are braced for what each side have promised will be a decisive phase of this war.